Measures of inequality serve as crucial tools for understanding the distribution of resources, wealth, and opportunities within societies. In any given population, inequality can manifest in various forms, including income, education, healthcare access, and more. These measures provide insights into the extent of disparities and the degree of equity within a community or nation. By quantifying the gap between different segments of the population, measures of inequality enable policymakers, economists, and social scientists to assess the effectiveness of policies aimed at promoting fairness and social justice. From the Gini coefficient to the Lorenz curve, these measures offer a lens through which we can analyze and address disparities, ultimately striving towards a more inclusive and equitable society.
Measures of Inequality
Gini Coefficient:
The Gini coefficient serves as a numerical indicator measuring societal inequality, ranging from 0 to 1. A value of 1 indicates maximum inequality, where all income or wealth concentrates in the hands of a single individual, while a value of 0 signifies perfect equality, with everyone receiving the same share. Essentially, the lower the Gini value, the more equal a society is. Notably, most OECD countries maintain a coefficient lower than 0.32.
India’s Gini:
In India, the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) conducts consumption surveys, providing a credible measure of inequality. The Gini coefficient for consumption expenditure, based on NSSO data, reveals the following:
- Urban Areas (2011-12): 0.38
- Rural Areas (2011-12): 0.29
Additionally, the India Human Development Survey (IHDS) reports income inequality in 2011-12 at 0.55. This growing disparity poses significant challenges:
- Undermining Economic Democracy:
- The widening wealth gap undermines the principles of economic democracy.
- Corruption and Cronyism:
- Inequality fosters an environment conducive to corruption and crony capitalism.
- Middle-Income Trap Concerns:
- There are apprehensions that the Indian economy may be entering a middle-income trap, driven by inequality.
- Production and Demand Disparities:
- The concentration of production for the top 10 percent of the population, coupled with an inability of the rest to generate demand, threatens economic stability.
- Threat to Economic Growth:
- Inequality emerges as a formidable threat to overall economic growth, highlighting the imperative need for addressing these disparities.
In conclusion, combating inequality is pivotal not only for social justice but also for sustaining robust economic development in India.
Lorenz Curve
The Lorenz curve, devised by Max O. Lorenz, serves as a graphical depiction of income inequality, typically based on Gini coefficient data. This curve finds application in gauging inequality across various domains, such as income, assets, or any other facility.
Gini Coefficient Derivation:
The Gini coefficient is derived through an analysis of two critical factors:
- Area Calculation:
- It involves calculating the area between the line of perfect equality and the line of perfect inequality on the Lorenz curve.
- Division Process:
- The Gini number is obtained by dividing the calculated area between the two lines (representing perfect equality and perfect inequality) by the area under the line of perfect inequality.
- The resulting Gini coefficient is always a value less than one, providing a quantifiable measure of the degree of inequality.
The Lorenz curve, thus, visually represents the distribution of income or assets, and the Gini coefficient offers a concise numerical reflection of the observed inequality. This methodology allows for a comprehensive understanding of disparities within a given system, facilitating targeted efforts to address and mitigate issues of inequality.
Ahluwalia-Chenery Welfare Index:
- Purpose: Addresses the limitation of GDP growth by considering the impact on different social groups.
- Measurement: Evaluates how each social group is affected by prosperity and adjusts growth numbers accordingly.
- Objective: Encourages inclusive growth, ensuring that the benefits of economic growth are distributed across all sections of society.
Kuznets Curve:
- Hypothesis (Simon Kuznets): Initially, as an economy develops, inequality increases, but eventually decreases.
- Shape: Resembles an inverted U-curve.
- Critique (Thomas Piketty): Recent research, such as Thomas Piketty’s work, challenges the Kuznets Curve, showing a U-curve in trends of inequality in advanced nations since 1980.
- Policy Influence: Piketty emphasizes the role of policies, particularly those supporting a Keynesian welfare state and a strong labor movement, in shaping inequality trends.
Piketty’s Findings:
- Inequality Trends: Contrary to Kuznets Curve, Piketty’s data shows a U-curve in inequality trends in the US, Japan, and Europe since 1980.
- Policy Impact: Decline in inequality from 1914 to 1974 attributed to Keynesian welfare state policies and strong labor movements.
- Market Forces: Shift towards greater market forces since the 1980s led to a rise in inequality.
- Wealth Dynamics: In slow-growing economies, inherited wealth gains disproportionate importance.
Palma Ratio:
- Definition: Ratio of income share of the top 10% to that of the bottom 40%.
- Used by: Oxfam.
- Objective: Provides an alternative perspective to inequality assessment compared to the Gini index.
Key Considerations:
- Knowledge and Skill Diffusion: Piketty emphasizes the role of knowledge and skill diffusion in moderating inequality.
- State Policies: Policies on education, access to training, and skill development are crucial for addressing inequality.
Conclusion: The Ahluwalia-Chenery Welfare Index, critique of the Kuznets Curve, and the Palma Ratio highlight the evolving approaches to measuring and understanding economic inequality. Incorporating these indices alongside traditional measures enriches the analysis of inclusive growth and the impact of policies on societal well-being.
Inter-Group Equality and Inclusiveness:
Disparities Among Groups:
- Disparities exist among various identity groups, including caste, gender, minorities, and differently-abled individuals.
- Inclusiveness from a group perspective involves addressing disparities and considering the overall status of the group in relation to the general population.
Angus Deaton’s Contribution:
- Angus Deaton, Nobel laureate in Economics, has analyzed consumption, poverty, and welfare, differentiating data to address disparities related to women, caste, region, etc.
FAQs
1. What is a measure of inequality?
- A measure of inequality quantifies the extent of disparities in the distribution of resources, wealth, or opportunities within a population.
2. What is the Gini coefficient?
- The Gini coefficient is a widely used measure of inequality that ranges from 0 to 1, where 0 represents perfect equality (everyone has the same income) and 1 represents perfect inequality (one person has all the income).
3. How is the Lorenz curve used to understand inequality?
- The Lorenz curve is a graphical representation of income or wealth distribution within a population. It plots cumulative income or wealth on the horizontal axis against the cumulative share of the population on the vertical axis. The greater the distance the curve is from the line of perfect equality, the greater the level of inequality.
4. What does the Palma ratio measure?
- The Palma ratio is another measure of income inequality, focusing on the income share of the top 10% of the population compared to the bottom 40%. It helps highlight the concentration of income within the top percentile relative to the broader population.
5. How does the Atkinson index differ from other measures of inequality?
- The Atkinson index considers not only the extent of inequality but also the society’s aversion to it. It incorporates a parameter (often denoted as “ε”) that reflects the society’s inequality aversion. A higher value of ε indicates higher aversion to inequality, thus giving more weight to lower-income individuals’ welfare.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
