Domestic workers form an indispensable backbone of households worldwide, yet their labor often remains invisible and undervalued. From nannies nurturing children to housekeepers maintaining homes, domestic workers play multifaceted roles crucial for the functioning of modern society. However, despite their vital contributions, they frequently encounter a myriad of challenges ranging from exploitation and abuse to lack of legal protections. This essay examines the various issues faced by domestic workers globally, delving into the complexities of their work conditions, and explores the existing laws and regulations aimed at safeguarding their rights. By shedding light on these crucial topics, we can strive towards creating a more just and equitable environment for this essential yet marginalized workforce.
Domestic Workers: Issues and Laws
Definition and Classification:
- As per the International Labour Organisation (ILO) Domestic Workers Convention, 2011, domestic work encompasses tasks performed within or for households. Domestic workers, defined within an employment relationship, are engaged in such activities. Occasional or sporadic domestic work not on an occupational basis doesn’t classify one as a domestic worker.
Current Status:
- Estimates suggest around 4.8 million domestic workers in India, with approximately 2.9 million being female. Women’s employment in domestic work constitutes 3.5% of the total female workforce. Domestic workers hold the third-largest share of employment after agriculture and construction. However, advocacy groups like the National Domestic Workers’ Movement claim a much higher figure, exceeding 50 million domestic workers.
Urban Concentration:
- Over 66% of domestic workers are employed in urban areas, reflecting a significant urban concentration. The last decade has witnessed a rapid 75% increase in the number of women and girls engaged in domestic work.
Education and Skill Levels:
- The majority of domestic workers in India have minimal education, often being illiterate or possessing basic education. Low-skilled tasks define their job roles.
Child Labor in Domestic Work:
- Alarming figures indicate that approximately 200,000 children are employed as domestic help and in dhabas, emphasizing the prevalence of child labor within this sector.
Challenges Confronting Domestic Workers in India:
1. Substandard Working Conditions:
- Domestic workers often face the denial of minimum wages and lack social security coverage, exposing them to exploitation.
- Live-in workers, in particular, are susceptible to physical abuse and harassment due to their vulnerable positions.
- Many domestic workers, often poor migrants with limited skills, endure extended working hours.
2. Legal Protection Gaps:
- Domestic workers lack coverage under any specific Act, leaving them without legal protection.
- Proposed bills like the Domestic Workers (Registration, Social Security, and Welfare) Bill and the Draft Policy on Domestic Workers await approval since 2010 and 2017, respectively.
- Absence of regulations regarding working conditions contributes to continued vulnerability and exploitation.
3. Implementation Challenges:
- While domestic work was included in the scheduled employment under the Minimum Wages Act (1948), implementation remains inadequate.
- Only 13 States/UTs have passed legislation ensuring minimum wages for domestic workers.
- The Unorganized Workers’ Social Security Act (2008) mandates welfare boards, but several states have not complied.
4. Insufficient Data:
- The lack of reliable data on the number of domestic workers hampers planning and resource allocation.
- Estimates vary widely from 4 million to 50 million, posing challenges to formulating effective plans.
5. Role of Informal Placement Agencies:
- Informal placement agencies and housekeeping companies often prioritize profits over worker rights.
- Lack of scrutiny of their operations contributes to the exploitation of domestic workers.
6. Neglect of Domestic Labour Rights:
- Legislation such as the Industry Disputes Act (1947), Employee’s Provident Fund Act (1952), and Factories Act (1948) fails to recognize domestic work in private households as legitimate ‘work.’
7. Limited Unionisation:
- A small fraction of domestic workers is unionized or part of organized groups.
- In the absence of unionization, their bargaining power for better wages is diminished, leaving them without support in cases of exploitation and abuse.
Initiatives for the Welfare of Domestic Workers:
Constitutional Safeguards:
- Article 23 (Fundamental Rights): Prohibits human trafficking, forced labor, and begar, safeguarding individuals’ rights against exploitation.
- Article 39(e) (Directive Principles): Encourages the state to prevent abuse of individuals’ health and strength, ensuring work suitability based on age and strength.
Legislative Inclusions:
- Unorganized Workers’ Social Security Act, 2008: Provides social security to domestic workers.
- Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013: Addresses workplace harassment, including domestic work settings.
- Child Labour Act: Restricts children under 14 from engaging in domestic work.
- Juvenile Justice Act, 2000: Rescues workers under 18 from exploitative conditions.
Government Schemes:
- Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY): Extended to cover domestic workers, ensuring health coverage.
- Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana: Encompasses domestic workers for comprehensive health benefits.
Digital Initiatives:
- e-Shram Portal: Aims to register 38 crore unorganized workers, including domestic workers.
Voluntary Pledge for Employers:
- Employers’ Pledge for Decent Work: Launched and adopted by major employer organizations, promoting fair work practices for domestic workers.
National Survey:
- All India Survey on Domestic Workers (DW): Initiated by the Union Minister for Labour and Employment, aiming to gather comprehensive data.
Global Collaborations:
- Palermo Protocol: Integrated into Indian law, defines and combats trafficking in persons.
- ILO and European Commission Collaboration: Develops operational indicators to combat human trafficking.
- ILO Convention 29 (1930): Defines forced labor.
- ILO Convention 189: Advocates for decent working conditions for domestic workers globally.
FAQs
Q: What are the common issues faced by domestic workers?
Domestic workers often face issues such as low wages, long hours without overtime pay, lack of job security, verbal and physical abuse, discrimination, and inadequate access to healthcare and other benefits.
Q: What laws protect domestic workers?
Laws protecting domestic workers vary by country and region. However, some common legal protections include minimum wage laws, overtime pay requirements, laws against discrimination and harassment, regulations regarding working hours and conditions, and provisions for rest periods and time off.
Q: Are domestic workers entitled to the same rights as other workers?
Yes, domestic workers should be entitled to the same rights and protections as other workers. However, in many places, domestic workers have historically been excluded from certain labor laws and protections. Efforts are underway in many countries to extend legal protections to domestic workers and ensure they are treated fairly and equitably.
Q: How can employers support domestic workers and ensure their rights are respected?
Employers can support domestic workers by paying fair wages, providing benefits such as health insurance and paid time off, establishing clear expectations and boundaries, providing a safe and respectful work environment, and addressing any concerns or grievances promptly and fairly.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
