In a landmark decision echoing the evolving societal norms and values, the Supreme Court has struck down the archaic provision criminalizing adultery, heralding a new era of personal autonomy and individual freedom. With this ruling, the highest court has unequivocally affirmed the right to privacy and equality within marriages, recognizing the need to discard outdated moral judgments from the legal sphere. This groundbreaking verdict not only marks a significant legal milestone but also underscores the judiciary’s commitment to upholding modern principles of justice and human rights.
Section 497 of the IPC
It mandates that whoever has sexual intercourse with the wife of another man, without the consent or connivance of that man, such sexual intercourse not amounting the offence of rape is guilty of the offence of adultery and shall be punished.
The law does not punish his wife, since it presumes that only a man can seduce a woman into a sexual act, and that it is the husband who has suffered due to the sexual relationship of his wife, carried out without his consent. At the same time, the wife is not protected from similar behaviour committed by her husband.
Supreme Court Strikes Down Section 497:
- Historic Decision: The Supreme Court has declared the 158-year-old Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code, criminalizing adultery, as unconstitutional.
- Bench and Unanimous Verdict: A five-judge Bench, led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra, unanimously struck down Section 497 and Section 198 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
- Constitutional Violations: The court found Section 497 in violation of Article 21 (Right to life and personal liberty) and Article 14 (Right to equality).
- Privacy and Adultery: The judgment emphasized that criminalizing infidelity encroaches upon the privacy of individuals. While adultery may lead to marital issues, criminality is an excessive measure.
- Absence of Supporting Data: The court debunked claims suggesting chaos in sexual morality or an increase in divorce due to the abolition of adultery as a crime, citing the lack of supporting data.
- Equality and Dignity: The decision challenged the Doctrine of Coverture, stating that a woman does not lose her identity and legal rights after marriage. It asserted that the legal sovereignty of one sex over the other is incorrect.
- Autonomy and Sexual Choices: Marriage does not imply surrendering autonomy. The ability to make sexual choices is deemed essential to human liberty, even within private spaces.
- Abetment to Suicide Clause: The court clarified that if an aggrieved spouse ended her life due to adultery, it could be treated as abetment to suicide with proper evidence.
- Critique of Societal Norms: The judgment criticized societal imposition of virtues on women, objectification, and confinement to traditional roles while highlighting society’s indifference to issues like rape, honor killings, and gender-based crimes.
Court’s Rationale in Decriminalizing Adultery:
- Anomalies in Existing Law: The court highlighted the anomalies in the existing law, where an adulterous relationship was not considered an offence if the married woman had her husband’s consent.
- Matrimonial Home Sanctity: The law didn’t allow a wife to prosecute her husband or his lover for violating the sanctity of the matrimonial home, creating a one-sided legal scenario.
- Gender Discrimination: Section 497 discriminated on grounds of sex, permitting only a husband to prosecute the man involved with his wife. It also ignored cases where the husband had affairs with unmarried, divorced, or widowed women.
- Violation of Fundamental Rights: The court emphasized the fundamental right to make choices as integral to human liberty and dignity. Section 497 restricted women’s autonomy in making these choices, violating Article 14 (equality) and Article 15.
- Changing Attitudes: The court acknowledged the shift from “ancient notions” where the man was seen as the seducer and the woman as the victim. It stated that a husband is neither the master of his wife nor has legal sovereignty over her.
- Arbitrary Nature of Section 497: Section 497 was deemed arbitrary for punishing only men in cases of adultery and treating a woman as her husband’s property.
- Global Decriminalization Trends: The court took cognizance of the global trend towards decriminalizing adultery, aligning India with contemporary legal developments in other jurisdictions.
FAQs
Q: Is adultery still a crime in India after the Supreme Court ruling?
No, adultery is no longer considered a criminal offense in India following the landmark ruling by the Supreme Court.
Q: What led to the Supreme Court’s decision to decriminalize adultery?
The Supreme Court ruled that Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalized adultery, was unconstitutional as it violated the fundamental rights to equality and privacy.
Q: What are the implications of the Supreme Court’s decision on adultery?
The ruling signifies a significant shift towards recognizing individual autonomy and personal choices in intimate relationships. It also marks a departure from outdated colonial-era laws that infringed upon privacy and autonomy.
Q: Does the decriminalization of adultery mean there are no legal consequences for extramarital affairs?
While adultery is no longer a criminal offense, it can still have legal ramifications in civil matters such as divorce proceedings, alimony, and child custody disputes. However, it is no longer a criminal offense punishable by imprisonment.
Q: How does the Supreme Court’s ruling align with changing societal attitudes towards relationships and marriage?
The decision reflects evolving societal norms that prioritize personal autonomy and equality within relationships. It acknowledges the need for laws to reflect contemporary values and respect individuals’ rights to make choices about their intimate lives without state interference.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
