The debate over the death penalty has raged for centuries, evolving alongside shifting moral, legal, and societal landscapes. Rooted in the fundamental questions of justice, deterrence, and human rights, this contentious issue has sparked impassioned arguments on both sides. Advocates of capital punishment often cite its potential deterrent effect and its capacity for justice in the face of heinous crimes. Conversely, opponents raise concerns about the risk of wrongful convictions, the inequities of its application, and the inherent immorality of state-sanctioned killing. As the debate persists, it forces us to confront complex ethical dilemmas and grapple with the very nature of justice and punishment in society.
Death Penalty in India:
- Purpose and Application:
- The death penalty aims to deter individuals by instilling fear of severe consequences for heinous crimes like murder and rape.
- It applies to offenses deeply affecting society, such as murder, rape, and rape with murder.
- Statistics and Reporting:
- The Death Penalty in India (2022) report by Project 39A indicates a significant increase, with 165 death sentences imposed in 2022— the highest in the last two decades.
- Project 39A, a criminal law reforms advocacy group in New Delhi, publishes the report, inspired by Article 39A of the Indian Constitution.
- Execution Method:
- Hanging is the primary method of execution in India, as stipulated under Section 354(5) of the Criminal Code of Procedure, 1973— “Hanging by the neck until dead.”
- Legal Remedies for Death Sentenced Individuals:
- A death sentence from a trial court requires High Court affirmation for finality.
- Article 137 of the Indian Constitution empowers the Supreme Court to review its orders.
- Review Petitions under Section 114 and Order 47 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) can be filed.
- Subsequent to review petition dismissal, individuals can file Curative Petitions in cases of gross violation of natural justice principles.
- The curative petition is examined by the three most senior judges and the bench that delivered the initial judgment.
- Mercy Petitions, filed within seven days of jail Superintendent’s dismissal notification, can be submitted.
- Article 72 and Article 161 of the Constitution grant the power to pardon the petitioner to the President and Governor, respectively.
Arguments Against the Death Penalty:
Lack of Deterrence Evidence:
- Critics contend that statistical evidence fails to establish the effectiveness of the death penalty as a deterrent to crime.
- The argument questions the premise that executions prevent others from committing heinous acts.
Incapacity to Deter Certain Offenders:
- Acknowledges that some individuals, due to mental illness or defects, may not be capable of being deterred.
- Crimes committed in extreme emotional states may occur without consideration of potential consequences, challenging the deterrence argument.
Ineffectiveness in Rape Cases:
- Despite the death penalty being prescribed for rape cases, the ongoing occurrence and increased brutality of rapes raise doubts about its efficacy as a deterrent.
- The argument questions whether capital punishment effectively curbs the incidence of such crimes.
Risk of Executing the Innocent:
- Raises the fundamental concern that flaws in the justice system may lead to the execution of innocent individuals.
- Emphasizes the fallibility of human justice and the inherent risk of wrongful executions.
Moral Objections to Retribution:
- Critics argue that retribution, as a basis for capital punishment, is morally questionable and represents a sanitized form of vengeance.
- This perspective questions the ethicality of the state administering death as a form of punishment.
International Abolition Trend:
- Points to the global trend of developed countries abolishing or imposing moratoriums on the death penalty.
- Cites the UN Secretary General’s report, indicating that a significant number of states have moved away from capital punishment.
Failure to Rehabilitate Prisoners:
- Contends that capital punishment does not offer the opportunity for rehabilitation and reintegration into society.
- Questions the effectiveness of the death penalty in addressing the root causes of criminal behavior and fostering prisoner rehabilitation.
FAQs
- Is the death penalty an effective deterrent to crime?
- Answer: While proponents argue that the death penalty deters crime, empirical evidence is inconclusive. Many studies suggest it doesn’t significantly deter crime more than alternative punishments such as life imprisonment.
- Does the death penalty provide closure for victims’ families?
- Answer: Opinions on this matter vary widely among victims’ families. Some find solace in the execution of the perpetrator, while others feel that it prolongs their pain by reopening wounds and does not provide true closure.
- Is the death penalty applied fairly across all demographics?
- Answer: Statistics indicate significant disparities in the application of the death penalty based on factors like race, socioeconomic status, and geography. Such inconsistencies raise concerns about the fairness and impartiality of the justice system.
- What about the risk of executing innocent people?
- Answer: The possibility of executing innocent individuals is a grave concern, highlighted by numerous cases of exonerations through DNA evidence. The irreversible nature of the death penalty makes this risk unacceptable to many critics.
- Is the death penalty morally justifiable?
- Answer: The morality of the death penalty is a deeply divisive issue. Opponents argue that it violates the sanctity of life and undermines the principles of justice and human dignity. Proponents, however, contend that it is a just response to heinous crimes and serves as a form of retribution and justice for victims and society.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
