Euthanasia, often referred to as mercy killing, is a topic that sparks profound ethical, moral, and legal debates worldwide. It involves the deliberate ending of a person’s life to relieve them from suffering, especially when they are terminally ill or in a vegetative state. This contentious issue intersects with the concept of a living will, a legal document that outlines a person’s preferences for medical treatment in case they become incapacitated and unable to communicate their wishes. Together, euthanasia and living wills delve into the complex realms of autonomy, dignity, and the right to die with dignity, raising crucial questions about individual rights, medical ethics, and societal values.
Living Will in India:
The concept of a living will gained legal recognition in India through the 2018 judgment in Common Cause vs. Union of India & Anr, which permitted passive euthanasia. This ruling emerged from the Aruna Shanbaug Case, where the debate centered around advocating mercy killing for Aruna. The guidelines outlined the execution of the living will and the approval process by a medical board. The court asserted that mentally competent adults have the right to refuse medical treatment, including withdrawal from life-saving devices.
Legal History:
The Supreme Court’s 2018 decision legalized passive euthanasia, contingent upon the presence of a ‘living will.’ A living will must be a written document specifying actions to be taken if the individual cannot make their own medical decisions. In cases where no living will exists, family members can approach the High Court to seek permission for passive euthanasia. The Supreme Court’s 2018 ruling recognized living wills of terminally-ill patients entering a permanent vegetative state.
Guidelines mandated the signing of the living will in the presence of witnesses and countersigning by a Judicial Magistrate of First Class (JMFC). Although Parliament was expected to enact legislation, it has not occurred, leaving the 2018 judgment as the definitive set of directions on euthanasia.
Pre-2018 Context:
- P Rathinam vs Union Of India, 1994: The Supreme Court deemed Section 309 of the IPC, which criminalized suicide attempts, as “cruel and irrational.”
- Gian Kaur vs The State Of Punjab, 1996: A later court decision overturned P Rathinam, stating that the right to life under Article 21 did not include the right to die, requiring legislation for euthanasia.
- Aruna Ramchandra Shanbaug vs Union Of India & Ors, 2011: The court allowed passive euthanasia for Aruna Shanbaug, making a distinction between ‘active’ and ‘passive’ euthanasia.
Post-SC Order Changes on Living Will:
- Medical Board Formation: Previously, both medical boards were formed by the hospital and Collector; now, the hospital alone is responsible for constituting both boards.
- Experience Requirement: The mandatory 20 years of experience for doctors has been relaxed to five years.
- Magistrate Approval: The need for Magistrate approval has been replaced by a requirement for intimation to the Magistrate.
- Witnesses: Initially requiring two witnesses and a Magistrate’s signature, the living will can now be signed by a notary or gazetted officer in the presence of two witnesses.
- Appeal to High Court: If the hospital’s medical boards deny permission, kin can appeal to the High Court, which will form a new medical team.
Global Perspectives:
- Netherlands, Luxembourg, Belgium: Allow both euthanasia and assisted suicide for those facing “unbearable suffering” with no chance of improvement.
- Switzerland: Bans euthanasia but permits assisted dying in the presence of a doctor or physician.
- Canada: Originally planned to allow euthanasia and assisted dying for mentally ill patients by March 2023; the decision faces criticism, and implementation may be delayed.
- United States: Varied laws across states, with euthanasia allowed in some, including Washington, Oregon, and Montana.
- United Kingdom: Considers euthanasia illegal and equivalent to manslaughter.
Q: What is euthanasia?
Euthanasia, also known as mercy killing, is the intentional ending of a person’s life to relieve suffering. It can be voluntary (with the consent of the patient) or involuntary (without the patient’s consent). Euthanasia is a highly debated ethical and legal issue, with proponents arguing for the right to die with dignity and opponents concerned about potential abuses and the sanctity of life.
Q: What is a living will?
A living will, also known as an advance directive, is a legal document that allows individuals to specify their preferences for medical treatment in case they become incapacitated and unable to communicate their wishes. It typically includes instructions regarding life-sustaining treatments such as resuscitation, mechanical ventilation, and tube feeding. A living will helps ensure that a person’s wishes regarding end-of-life care are respected.
Q: Is euthanasia legal?
The legality of euthanasia varies greatly depending on the jurisdiction. Some countries and states have legalized euthanasia under certain conditions, often with strict safeguards in place to prevent abuse. In other places, euthanasia remains illegal and is considered a criminal offense. It’s important to consult the laws of your specific location to understand the legal status of euthanasia.
Q: What are the ethical considerations surrounding euthanasia?
Ethical debates surrounding euthanasia often revolve around issues such as autonomy, suffering, and the sanctity of life. Proponents argue that individuals have the right to choose a peaceful death if they are suffering unbearably and have no hope of recovery. Opponents raise concerns about the potential for coercion, the slippery slope toward involuntary euthanasia, and the importance of preserving life even in the face of suffering.
Q: How can I ensure my end-of-life wishes are respected?
To ensure that your end-of-life wishes are respected, it’s important to create a comprehensive advance directive, including a living will and a durable power of attorney for healthcare. Discuss your preferences with your loved ones and healthcare providers, and make sure they know where to find your documents in case of emergency. Regularly review and update your advance directive to reflect any changes in your health or preferences.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
