The tax-to-GDP ratio serves as a critical indicator of a nation’s fiscal health, reflecting the extent to which a government relies on taxation to fund its expenditures relative to the size of its economy. This ratio, expressed as a percentage, provides valuable insights into a country’s taxation policies, economic structure, and overall fiscal sustainability. High ratios may indicate robust revenue collection but could also suggest a heavy tax burden on citizens and businesses, potentially dampening economic growth. Conversely, low ratios may signal inadequate revenue generation, posing challenges for funding essential public services and infrastructure. Consequently, policymakers often closely monitor and analyze the Tax-to-GDP ratio to assess fiscal performance, formulate effective tax policies, and ensure sustainable economic development.
Tax to GDP Ratio in India:
- Tax Buoyancy and Historical Trends:
- The tax to GDP ratio is influenced by economic growth, personal incomes, corporate profits, and consumption.
- Tax buoyancy occurs when tax collections rise along with economic growth.
- India’s gross tax collections reached the highest level of 11.6% in 2017-2018.
- Decline in Tax to GDP Ratio:
- The gross tax to GDP ratio declined to 10.9% in 2018 and further to less than 10% in FY20.
- Factors contributing to the decline include decreased collections from customs duties and corporation tax, while excise duty posted marginal growth.
- The economic slump, particularly in FY20, contributed to the decline in tax collections.
- States’ GST Collections Impact:
- India’s tax to GDP ratio becomes 16.6% when adding taxes and duties collected by states and local bodies.
- Statistically, the gross tax collections of the Government of India have decreased since 2017-2018 due to states collecting their own GST.
- Comparison with Other Countries:
- Tax to GDP ratios vary globally. In the EU-28 in 2015, tax revenue stood at 40.0% of GDP.
- BRICS countries have different tax to GDP ratios: Brazil (35.6%), South Africa (28.8%), Russia (23%), and China (19.4%).
- Developed countries like Sweden, France, Denmark have higher tax to GDP ratios, reflecting their higher per capita income and the ability to pay higher taxes.
- International Comparisons:
- USA has a tax to GDP ratio of 25.4%.
- France has a high tax to GDP ratio of 45%, while Denmark’s is even higher at 48.6%.
Note: The tax to GDP ratio is a crucial economic indicator, reflecting the fiscal health of a country and its ability to generate revenue for public expenditure. Economic factors, policy changes, and global events can influence this ratio over time.
Factors Contributing to India’s Relatively Low Tax to GDP Ratio:
- Developing Country Status:
- India is a developing country with lower per capita income, influencing the ability to collect higher taxes.
- Large Informal Sector:
- The presence of a substantial informal sector, where economic activities go unreported, contributes to lower tax collections.
- Exemption of Agricultural Income:
- Agricultural income is exempt from taxation, impacting the overall tax revenue.
- Tax Exemptions and Expenditures:
- Numerous tax exemptions and expenditures reduce the effective tax base, limiting revenue generation.
- Parallel Economy:
- The existence of a parallel or shadow economy, involving unreported transactions, affects the accuracy of tax assessments and collections.
- Capacity Constraints in Tax Machinery:
- The tax administration may face capacity constraints, impacting its ability to effectively assess and collect taxes.
Impact of Economic Reforms on Tax to GDP Ratio:
- Formalization of the Economy:
- Since 2016-2017, the formalization of the economy has gained momentum, driven by measures like demonetization and the implementation of GST.
- Digital Payments and Increased Tax Filings:
- Demonetization and emphasis on digital payments have resulted in more people filing tax returns.
- GST and Higher Compliance:
- GST has increased compliance due to features like input tax set off, making it harder for entities to evade taxes.
- Operation Clean Money:
- Initiatives like Operation Clean Money were launched to curb unaccounted money funneled into bank accounts post-demonetization.
Recent Trends in Tax to GDP Ratio:
- Impact of Rationalized Tax Rates:
- Rationalization of tax rates has contributed to a rising tax-GDP ratio.
- Factors Leading to Increased Ratio (Except Pandemic Year):
- More economic activity (GDP growth).
- Broadening of the tax base with more taxable economic actions.
- Better enforcement and compliance.
Note: The tax to GDP ratio is a dynamic indicator influenced by economic, regulatory, and enforcement factors. Recent reforms and initiatives have aimed at improving compliance, broadening the tax base, and enhancing overall revenue generation.
FAQs
Q: What is the Tax-to-GDP Ratio?
A: The Tax-to-GDP ratio is a measure of the total tax revenue collected by the government as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of a country. It indicates the level of taxation relative to the overall economic output of the nation.
Q: Why is the Tax-to-GDP Ratio important?
A: The Tax-to-GDP ratio is an essential indicator of a country’s fiscal health and its capacity to generate revenue. A higher ratio typically signifies a larger tax base and greater government resources for public spending on infrastructure, social welfare programs, and other essential services.
Q: What factors influence the Tax-to-GDP Ratio?
A: Several factors can influence the Tax-to-GDP ratio, including tax policies, economic growth rates, demographics, informal economy size, tax evasion, and enforcement effectiveness. Changes in these factors can lead to fluctuations in the ratio over time.
Q: What is the ideal Tax-to-GDP Ratio?
A: There is no universally ideal Tax-to-GDP ratio, as it varies depending on the country’s economic structure, development level, and societal preferences. However, economists often suggest that a balanced ratio is crucial, ensuring adequate revenue collection without stifling economic growth or burdening taxpayers excessively.
Q: How can governments improve the Tax-to-GDP Ratio?
A: Governments can enhance the Tax-to-GDP ratio through various measures, such as broadening the tax base, improving tax compliance and enforcement mechanisms, implementing fair and efficient tax policies, reducing tax evasion and avoidance, fostering economic growth, and promoting transparency and accountability in public finances.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
