In the ever-evolving landscape of international relations, the concept of “A chance to reboot relations with the West” emerges as a pivotal opportunity for nations striving to redefine their diplomatic and economic engagements. This prospect underscores a crucial moment for countries to reassess and revitalize their ties with Western powers, fostering collaboration and mutual benefit. As global challenges such as climate change, economic instability, and geopolitical tensions intensify, seizing this chance becomes imperative. Strengthening these relationships can lead to enhanced cooperation, and technological exchange, and bolstered economic growth, thereby paving the way for a more stable and prosperous global community.
Tags: GS – 2, IR- Global Groupings– Groupings & Agreements – Involving India & Affecting India’s Interests
Context:
- As a frequent G7 participant, India seeks to deepen collaboration with the “collective West.” With the West eager to include India in global governance, the upcoming G7 summit in Italy is a prime opportunity for India to reboot its ties with Western nations.
| What is G-7? About: The G7 is an informal bloc of industrialised democracies, the United States, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, and the United Kingdom (UK), that meets annually to discuss issues such as global economic governance, international security, and, most recently, artificial intelligence (AI). History: The United States, France, Italy, Japan, the UK, and West Germany formed the Group of Six in 1975 to provide a venue for noncommunist powers to address pressing economic concerns, which included inflation and a recession sparked by the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) oil embargo.Canada joined in 1976 and The European Union (EU) has participated fully in the G7 since 1981 as a “non enumerated” member.Russia belonged to the forum from 1998 through 2014, when the bloc was known as the Group of Eight (G8), but the country was suspended following its annexation of Ukraine’s Crimea region. Secretariat: The G7 does not have a formal charter or a secretariat.The presidency, which rotates among member countries each year, is in charge of setting the agenda.The 50th G7 Summit is set to be held from 13th June to 15th June 2024 in the city of Fasano in Apulia, Italy (India is invited). |
What Is the West in Geopolitical Terms?
Geographic Scope:
- The West until recently referred to Western Europe and the lands it settled, primarily North America and Australasia.
- The debate about the inclusion of Eastern Europe-considered by some as equal to that of the former Soviet sphere of influence-continues.
- However, this definition is not so clear-cut anymore. The world’s growing interconnectedness challenges the clear-cut distinction between “West” and “East.”
Cultural Features:
- Greco-Roman Legacy Western culture borrows significantly from the way of life, philosophies, and governance of ancient Greece and Rome, where reason, logic, and rights of individuals were stressed.
- Christianity has profoundly influenced Western values and institutions, even though religious practices have become increasingly diversified; this influence stems from Catholicism and Protestantism primarily.
Political and Economic Systems:
- Democracy is a system of representative government with individual freedoms and liberties that is a cornerstone of political systems in the West.
- Free-market economies with private ownership and competition define most Western economies.
- The West emphasises a legal system based on established laws and procedures, ensuring fairness and accountability.
Why Does India Need to Reboot Its Relations with the West?
Managing the China Challenge:
- Rising Assertiveness: China’s actions in the Indo-Pacific and its border tensions with India are significant challenges.
- Strategic Competitor: The West, especially the U.S., sees China as a strategic rival.
- Improved Relations: Stronger India-West ties would enhance coordination on economic, diplomatic, and military strategies against China.
- Joint Military Exercise: India and the US’s Tiger Triumph 2024 exercise shows a commitment to security collaboration.
Balancing Relations Alongside Russia:
- Historical Ties: India’s defence ties with Russia strain relations with the West, especially post-Ukraine conflict.
- Energy Security: Increased Russian oil imports despite sanctions highlight energy concerns.
- Rebooting Relations: Clarifying India’s stance and finding common ground on energy and regional stability are key.
Managing the US-China Technological Decoupling:
- Tech Wars: US-China tech decoupling in AI and 5G presents a challenge for India.
- Non-alignment Risks: Staying non-aligned could hinder India’s tech and economic growth.
- Balanced Approach: Seeking a balanced stance could allow India to access Western tech while maintaining strategic autonomy.
Reshaping the Global Trade Architecture:
- WTO Challenges: The global trade order is shifting with new frameworks like the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity.
- Proactive Engagement: India must engage to address issues like data localization and digital taxation.
- Pivotal Player: A proactive stance could make India a key player in new trade rules.
Navigating the Geopolitics of Climate Change and Energy Transition:
- Strategic Competition: Climate change has become a strategic issue, with the West pushing for renewables and tech weaponization.
- Energy Security: India’s energy needs and leadership in solar initiatives make it a crucial partner.
- Balanced Approach: A revamped partnership could aid in climate finance, tech transfers, and a balanced energy transition.
Collaborating on Regional Connectivity:
- Integrated Vision: India’s regional connectivity plans, like the India-Middle East-Europe Corridor, need Western cooperation.
- Western Cooperation: Support in financing, capacity-building, and aligning with the rules-based order is essential.
What are the Friction Points Between India and West?
Differences on Global Governance and Reforms:
- India seeks changes in global governance to reflect shifting power dynamics.
- Some Western nations resist reforms that would reduce their influence, causing friction with India’s ambitions.
Intellectual Property Rights and Technology Transfers:
- India’s stance on IPR and production of affordable generics often clashes with Western pharmaceutical interests.
- The West is wary of transferring sensitive technologies to India, fearing diversion or leakage.
Strategic Autonomy vs. Alignment Expectations:
- India’s pursuit of strategic autonomy conflicts with Western desires for closer alignment, especially regarding the Russia-Ukraine War.
- India’s all-alignment policy is seen as pragmatic by India but perceived as reluctance to take sides by the West.
Divergent Approaches to Regional Security:
- India’s regional security strategies sometimes diverge from Western views.
- India’s cautious approaches to Myanmar’s political crisis and the Taliban’s takeover of Afghanistan have caused friction with Western policies.
The Khalistan Issue:
- The Khalistan movement, supported by elements within the Indian diaspora in countries like Canada and the UK, strains relations.
- India accuses these nations of allowing platforms for anti-India activities, complicating bilateral ties.
Defense Cooperation and Arms Exports:
- India’s defence collaboration with Russia, including the procurement of the S-400 system, creates tension with the West.
- Although India received a CAATSA waiver, recent concerns about its Russian ties have resurfaced, particularly from the U.S.
How Can India and the West Reconcile Their Differences?
Establish a Plurilateral Tech Alliance:
- India and the West could establish a plurilateral technology alliance to develop standards for critical technologies like AI, quantum computing, and cyber security.
- This would facilitate joint research, knowledge sharing, and co-development, ensuring a level playing field and protecting strategic interests.
Create a Renewable Energy and Climate Innovation Fund:
- India and the West could jointly create a fund dedicated to clean energy research, development, and deployment.
- Projects in green hydrogen, carbon capture, sustainable aviation fuels, and climate-resilient infrastructure would be supported, fostering collaboration and addressing technology transfer and finance concerns.
Joint Framework for Responsible Space Exploration:
- India and the West could develop a joint framework for responsible space exploration and governance.
- This would address sustainable space resource utilisation, space debris prevention, and the peaceful use of space, promoting cooperation while respecting strategic interests.
Focus on Regional Trade Agreements:
- Instead of a pan-India-EU FTA, India could pursue regional trade agreements with specific countries, like the recent TEPA with the European Free Trade Association.
- These agreements allow for faster progress and cater to diverse economic interests.
Issue-Based Alignment:
- India could adopt an “issue-based alignment” approach, cooperating on mutual concerns while maintaining its independent stance on other matters.
- Establishing dialogue mechanisms would help address misperceptions about India’s strategic autonomy, ensuring transparency and open communication.
| UPSC Civil Services Examination, Previous Year Questions (PYQs): Prelims Q:1 Recently, India signed a deal known as ‘Action Plan for Prioritisation and Implementation of Cooperation Areas in the Nuclear Field’ with which of the following countries? (2019) a) Japan b) Russia c) The United Kingdom d) The United States of America Ans: (b) Q:2 Among the following Presidents of India, who was also the Secretary General of the Non-Aligned Movement for some period? (2009) a) Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan b) Varahagiri Venkatagiri c) Giani Zail Singh d) Dr. Shanker Dayal Sharma Ans: (c) |
Source: IE
FAQs
FAQ 1: What is the primary focus of the editorial “A Chance to Reboot Relations with the West”?
Answer: The editorial focuses on the potential opportunities and challenges in improving diplomatic, economic, and strategic relations between a country (often India in the UPSC context) and Western nations. It emphasizes the need for a balanced approach that leverages mutual interests while addressing geopolitical shifts and domestic priorities.
FAQ 2: Why is it important for India to reboot its relations with Western countries?
Answer: Rebooting relations with Western countries is important for India to enhance trade opportunities, secure strategic partnerships, gain access to advanced technology, and improve its geopolitical standing. Strong ties with the West can also help India in addressing global challenges such as climate change, terrorism, and economic instability.
FAQ 3: What are the key areas of cooperation between India and the West that the editorial highlights?
Answer: The editorial highlights several key areas of cooperation, including:
- Economic and Trade Relations: Enhancing bilateral trade agreements and investment opportunities.
- Defense and Security: Strengthening defense partnerships and security cooperation.
- Technology and Innovation: Collaborating on technological advancements and research.
- Climate Change: Joint efforts to tackle environmental challenges.
- Cultural and Educational Exchange: Promoting people-to-people connections through cultural and educational programs.
FAQ 4: What challenges does India face in improving its relations with Western countries?
Answer: India faces several challenges in improving its relations with Western countries, such as:
- Geopolitical Tensions: Balancing relations with rival powers, like China and Russia.
- Trade Barriers: Navigating protectionist policies and trade disputes.
- Human Rights Issues: Addressing Western concerns about human rights and democratic values.
- Domestic Policies: Aligning domestic reforms with international expectations.
- Strategic Autonomy: Maintaining strategic autonomy while deepening ties with Western allies.
FAQ 5: How can India effectively leverage its relations with the West to achieve its national interests?
Answer: India can effectively leverage its relations with the West by:
- Diplomatic Engagement: Proactively engaging in diplomatic dialogues to address mutual concerns and explore new avenues of cooperation.
- Economic Reforms: Implementing economic reforms to attract Western investments and enhance trade relations.
- Strategic Partnerships: Strengthening defense and security collaborations to counter regional threats and enhance strategic stability.
- Technological Collaboration: Partnering with Western countries on innovation, technology transfer, and research initiatives.
- Soft Power Diplomacy: Promoting cultural, educational, and people-to-people exchanges to build goodwill and mutual understanding.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on +91-9773890604.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
