Boundaries are important in geopolitics. Explain. What issues develop from the inclusionary and exclusionary aspects of borders? – UPSC Geography Optional Mains – 2021

Explore the significance of boundaries in geopolitics and their impact on international relations, as per the UPSC Geography Optional Mains exam for 2021. Delve into the role of boundaries in demarcating territories, asserting sovereignty, and delineating geopolitical interests. Examine the complexities arising from both inclusive and exclusive aspects of borders, including issues of identity, migration, and resource distribution. Analyze the challenges posed by inclusionary borders in managing diversity and fostering unity, as well as the tensions stemming from exclusionary borders in exacerbating conflict and inequality. Gain insights into the geopolitical implications of boundary dynamics, essential for understanding global politics and navigating contemporary geopolitical challenges. This examination offers a nuanced perspective on the multifaceted role of boundaries in shaping geopolitical landscapes.

Answer:

Introduction:

Boundaries in geopolitics serve as physical or conceptual lines that define the extent of a territory. They play a crucial role in shaping political, economic, and social interactions between nations.

Body:

Issues from Inclusionary Aspects of Borders:

1. Cultural Diversity and Identity: Inclusionary borders may lead to the blending of diverse cultures, fostering a sense of unity but potentially eroding distinct identities.
   • Example: The European Union’s open borders encourage cultural exchange but have also raised concerns about the preservation of individual national identities.

2. Economic Integration: Inclusive borders can facilitate economic cooperation, but may also raise concerns about resource distribution and economic imbalances among neighboring nations.
   • NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) exemplifies inclusive borders promoting
     economic collaboration while also generating debates about job displacement and trade
     imbalances.
3. Security Challenges:Collaborative security measures within inclusive borders may arise, but the risk of security threats spilling over from one country to another could increase.
   • The Schengen Area’s inclusive border policy enhances internal security but has faced
     challenges in managing the spillover of security threats.
4. Migration Pressures:Inclusionary borders might attract migration, leading to population movements that could strain resources and challenge social cohesion.
   • The inclusivity of Scandinavian borders has attracted migration, posing both
     opportunities and challenges for social integration and resource distribution.
5. Political Harmony or Disputes:While inclusive borders may promote political stability, they could also spark territorial disputes and power struggles among nations.
   • The Mekong River Commission fosters collaborative efforts among Southeast Asian
     nations, yet conflicting interests hinder effective environmental management.

Issues from Exclusionary Aspects of Borders:

1. Ethnic Tensions:Exclusionary borders may exacerbate ethnic tensions by separating communities, potentially leading to conflict and displacement.
   • The partition of India in 1947 created exclusive borders, contributing to enduring ethnic
     tensions between India and Pakistan.
2. Trade Barriers:Exclusive borders can hinder trade, imposing economic barriers that may result in strained international relations and economic decline.
   • Brexit introduced trade barriers between the UK and the EU, impacting economic
     relations and prompting concerns about the stability of the European market.
3. Isolationism and Nationalism: Exclusionary borders may fuel isolationist tendencies and
   nationalist sentiments, limiting global cooperation and diplomacy.
   • North Korea’s exclusive policies result in isolationism, fostering a strong nationalist
     sentiment but limiting international cooperation.
4. Humanitarian Concerns: Exclusionary policies might impede the delivery of humanitarian aid,
   exacerbating crises in border regions.
   • The Rohingya crisis highlights the challenges of delivering humanitarian aid across
     exclusive borders, exacerbating a dire situation.
5. Cross-Border Crime: Exclusionary borders may create havens for criminal activities, as law enforcement struggles with jurisdictional challenges.
   • The U.S.-Mexico border struggles with cross-border crime, emphasizing the difficulties in law enforcement collaboration due to jurisdictional issues.
6. Disparities in Development: Exclusive borders can contribute to economic disparities, fostering uneven development and perpetuating inequalities.
   • Exclusive borders in Africa have contributed to economic disparities, with certain regions facing slower development compared to others.

Conclusion:

Emphasizing diplomacy, international cooperation, and addressing the root causes of conflicts can pave the way for a more interconnected and harmonious global society. Recognizing the intricate relationship between borders and geopolitics is essential for fostering sustainable peace and development.

In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901. 

For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here

For Daily Updates and Study Material:

Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS

• 1. Learn through Videos – here
• 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
• 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
• 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here

Visit our YouTube Channel – here