Demonetization is a government-led action that strips a currency unit of its status as legal tender. One of the significant instances of demonetization occurred in India on November 8, 2016, when the government announced the demonetization of ₹500 and ₹1,000 banknotes. Individuals holding these notes were required to deposit them in banks and exchange them for new currency notes.
Historical Context:
- Prior Instances:
- Demonetization had occurred in India on two previous occasions, in 1946 and 1978. In both cases, the objective was to combat tax evasion associated with “black money” held outside the formal economic system.
- The 2016 demonetization decision differed as it was an executive decision, not enacted through an ordinance.
Pros of Demonetization:
- Combatting Black Money:
- Demonetization aims to target and eliminate black money, which is unaccounted wealth often associated with tax evasion.
- Addressing Social Issues:
- Black money is often used for funding illegal activities such as terrorism, gambling, human trafficking, and speculative practices. Demonetization can have positive effects in curbing these activities.
- Formalization and Digitization:
- The process encourages the formalization and digitization of the economy by promoting electronic transactions and reducing reliance on cash.
- Widening Tax Net:
- Demonetization can lead to a broader tax net as more individuals may file returns, providing the government with additional fiscal resources for welfare expenditure.
Cons of Demonetization:
- Inconvenience to the Public:
- People may face inconvenience in depositing invalidated notes and the time required to access their money from banks.
- Logistical Challenges:
- Implementing demonetization in a large economy poses logistical challenges, including the handling of a massive volume of currency transactions.
- Cost of Printing New Currency:
- The process incurs significant costs related to printing new currency notes and managing the transition.
- Limited Impact on Black Economy:
- Cash constitutes only a small part of the black economy. Demonetization, without a comprehensive strategy, may not fully succeed in addressing the issue.
Conclusion: Demonetization is a complex policy measure with potential benefits and challenges. Its success depends on effective implementation and the accompanying strategies to mitigate adverse effects on the public and the economy.
Urjit Patel Committee:
Formation and Purpose: In 2014, an expert committee was appointed to assess the existing monetary policy framework of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The committee was chaired by Urjit Patel, and its recommendations aimed to enhance the effectiveness and transparency of monetary policy in India.
Key Recommendations:
- Inflation Targeting:
- The committee recommended the adoption of inflation targeting as a key policy objective. The suggested target for inflation was set at 4 per cent, with a permissible band of ±2 per cent around this target.
- Inflation targeting involves a commitment to maintaining inflation within a specified range, providing clarity on the primary goal of monetary policy.
- Nominal Anchor – CPI Inflation:
- The committee proposed that the nominal anchor for the monetary policy framework should be defined in terms of headline Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation.
- CPI inflation, which reflects the changes in the cost of living, was considered a suitable metric to influence inflation expectations.
- Fiscal Deficit Reduction:
- The committee recommended the reduction of the fiscal deficit as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). This was seen as a complementary measure to support the inflation targeting framework.
- Monetary Policy Committee (MPC):
- One significant proposal was the establishment of a Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) to make monetary policy decisions. The MPC was suggested to be headed by the Governor of the RBI.
- The formation of an MPC aimed to bring a structured and collective approach to monetary policy decision-making, ensuring a diversity of perspectives.
Significance: The recommendations of the Urjit Patel Committee were instrumental in shaping the monetary policy framework in India. The adoption of inflation targeting provided a clear policy direction, and the establishment of an MPC aimed to enhance the governance and decision-making process within the RBI.
The subsequent years saw the operationalization of the inflation targeting framework and the establishment of the Monetary Policy Committee as key components of India’s monetary policy architecture.
FAQs
Q: What is demonetization?
A: Demonetization is the process by which a government invalidates the legal tender status of a certain currency unit, typically replacing it with new currency notes or coins. This move is often aimed at curbing issues like black money, counterfeit currency, and corruption.
Q: Why was demonetization implemented in India in 2016?
A: Demonetization in India was announced on November 8, 2016, by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The primary objectives were to curb corruption, black money, counterfeit currency, and to promote a digital economy. The sudden withdrawal of high-denomination currency notes (₹500 and ₹1000) aimed to tackle the issue of unaccounted wealth in the country.
Q: What were the immediate effects of demonetization in India?
A: The immediate effects of demonetization included long queues at banks and ATMs, cash shortages leading to economic disruption, a temporary slowdown in economic growth, and significant inconvenience to the public. However, it also led to a surge in digital transactions and increased tax compliance in the long term.
Q: Did demonetization achieve its intended objectives?
A: The success of demonetization in achieving its objectives remains a subject of debate. While it led to a temporary disruption in the economy, there were some positive outcomes such as increased tax compliance, a boost to digital payments, and a crackdown on black money and counterfeit currency. However, its long-term impact on curbing corruption and black money remains contested.
Q: What lessons can be learned from the demonetization experience?
A: The demonetization experience in India underscores the importance of careful planning, stakeholder consultation, and ensuring adequate infrastructure for the smooth transition to a new currency regime. It also highlights the need for complementary measures to address the root causes of corruption and black money, along with promoting financial inclusion and digital literacy to minimize the impact of such disruptive measures on the public.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
