Development often brings about significant changes, often for the better, but it can also lead to unintended consequences, notably displacement. As societies evolve economically, technologically, and socially, infrastructural projects, urbanization, and industrialization become prevalent. However, amidst the pursuit of progress, communities, and individuals frequently find themselves uprooted from their homes and traditional ways of life. This phenomenon of displacement, whether due to large-scale infrastructure projects, urban renewal initiatives, or environmental degradation, underscores the complex interplay between development and its human costs. Understanding the multifaceted nature of development leading to displacement is crucial in crafting sustainable and inclusive growth strategies that prioritize the well-being and rights of affected populations.
Development Leading to Displacement
Infrastructure stands as the bedrock of progress, driving economic growth, connectivity, and improved living standards. Across the globe, substantial investments are made in large-scale infrastructure projects, ranging from transportation networks to energy grids. In 2015, a staggering $9.5 trillion was allocated to infrastructure spending, constituting 14% of the global GDP. These projects not only propel economic development but also bear significant political implications, historically marking strides towards economic independence in the Global South. However, beneath the façade of progress lies a profound challenge—Development-Induced Displacement and Resettlement (DIDR), where individuals and communities are compelled to abandon their homes to make way for expansive development initiatives.
According to the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC) at the end of 2022, 71.1 million people were internally displaced as a result of conflict, violence, and disasters.
India, with its rapid economic growth and ambitious infrastructure projects, is no stranger to development-induced displacement. While these projects promise progress, the human toll, often obscured, becomes a critical concern. This article sheds light on the factors contributing to development-led displacement in the Indian context, supported by specific examples, facts, and data.
Scale of Displacement:
- Historical Context: India’s post-independence era witnessed large-scale industrialization, leading to significant displacement. The construction of dams, industries, and urbanization projects displaced millions.
- Contemporary Trends: Recent decades have seen a surge in large-scale projects, contributing to the displacement of communities. Between 2005 and 2016, over 21 million people were displaced due to development projects.
Types of Development Projects:
- Infrastructure Projects: Transportation, urban development, and power projects are major contributors to displacement. For instance, the Sardar Sarovar Dam displaced over 2,50,000 people.
- Industrial Expansion: The growth of industries has led to the acquisition of vast stretches of land, displacing both rural and tribal communities. The Posco steel plant project in Odisha displaced thousands.
- Urban Renewal: Development in urban areas often involves the clearance of slums and informal settlements, causing displacement. The Delhi Metro expansion is one such example.
Status of Development induced Displacement:
- Displacement in Development Projects:
- Dams, a focal point in development initiatives, often trigger significant controversies in India.
- Between 1950-1990, an estimated 18.5 million people were affected by displacement due to development projects.
- Scale of Dam Construction:
- The Central Water Commission reports over 3,300 dams built post-independence, with 1,000 more under construction.
- A study on 54 large dams by the Indian Institute of Public Administration reveals an average displacement of 44,182 people per dam.
- Pong Dam Displacement:
- Construction of the Pong Dam displaced over 21,000 families 25 years ago, lacking proper rehabilitation measures.
- Despite displacement, these families are yet to receive adequate rehabilitation benefits.
- Sardar Sarovar Dam Controversy:
- The Sardar Sarovar Dam on the Narmada, set to displace around 0.2 million people, faces uncertainty.
- The World Bank’s ‘Project Completion Report’ questions India’s operational and maintenance track record, leading to doubts about the project’s future.
- Impact on Indigenous Communities:
- Development projects, often located in remote areas, displace indigenous people who traditionally conserve these regions.
- Displacement results in the loss of livelihood, habitat, assets, social disruption, and detachment from ecosystems sustaining them.
- Threats from Globalization:
- Globalization poses a threat to indigenous communities as private conglomerates, including foreign multinationals, encroach upon rural lands.
- Proposed amendments to the 1894 Act may exacerbate displacement as it could facilitate easier land acquisition by private interests.
Rehabilitation Challenges:
- The 1894 Land Acquisition Act lacks emphasis on rehabilitation, focusing on cash compensation for loss.
- Government stance prioritizes ‘public purpose’ over rehabilitation, limiting the right of appeal for those facing land confiscation.
Challenges Faced by Displaced Populations:
- Inadequate Compensation: Compensation packages often fail to provide affected populations with fair value for their land and livelihoods.
- Poor Resettlement: Resettlement efforts frequently lack essential infrastructure, leaving displaced communities in substandard living conditions.
- Loss of Livelihood: Displaced individuals, especially those from agrarian backgrounds, face challenges in adapting to new environments, leading to loss of livelihood.
Legal Framework and Implementation:
- The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation, and Resettlement Act, 2013: This act provides number of safeguards for the process of acquisition manifestly fairer. It acknowledges a need for a system of rehabilitation and resettlement for those whose livelihoods are likely to be affected by the transfer of land.
- Forest Rights Act (2006): Aims to recognize and vest the forest rights and occupation in forest land in forest-dwelling communities. However, its implementation has been slow, contributing to further displacement.
FAQs
Q: What are the common causes of development leading to displacement?
Development projects such as infrastructure construction, urban renewal, and industrialization often require land acquisition, which can displace communities. Additionally, natural resource extraction, like mining or logging, can lead to displacement due to environmental degradation.
Q: How does development-induced displacement affect communities?
Displacement can disrupt social networks, cultural traditions, and livelihoods, leading to increased poverty, homelessness, and psychological distress among affected populations. Communities may also face challenges accessing basic services and suffer from loss of identity and social cohesion.
Q: What measures can be taken to mitigate the negative impacts of development-induced displacement?
Effective measures include transparent and inclusive decision-making processes, adequate compensation for affected individuals and communities, provision of alternative livelihood opportunities, access to basic services and infrastructure in resettlement areas, and implementation of comprehensive resettlement plans.
Q: Are there any international guidelines or standards addressing development-induced displacement?
Yes, organizations like the World Bank and the United Nations have established guidelines and standards, such as the World Bank’s Operational Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and the UN Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement, to ensure that development projects respect the rights of affected populations and minimize adverse impacts.
Q: How can communities advocate for their rights in the face of development-induced displacement?
Communities can engage in grassroots organizing, advocacy campaigns, and legal action to demand fair treatment, participation in decision-making processes, and adequate compensation for displacement. Building alliances with NGOs, human rights organizations, and legal aid groups can also strengthen their ability to advocate effectively.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
