Fintech in India: Promise, Progress, Innovation, and Regulation – UPSC Economy Notes

Definition: Fintech, short for financial technology, refers to technologically enabled financial innovations. It represents an emerging industry that utilizes technology to enhance various activities within the financial sector. Fintech encompasses a range of services, from mobile banking and investing to borrowing and cryptocurrency, with the aim of making financial services more accessible and efficient.

Characteristics of Fintech:

1. Technological Integration: Fintech leverages advancements in technology, such as smartphones, to deliver financial services.
2. Innovation: Fintech companies, both startups and established institutions, innovate to enhance or replace traditional financial services.
3. Agility: Fintech aims to provide agile and differentiated experiences for end-users, offering a wider range of options at competitive prices.

Fintech in India:

1. Global Recognition: India is recognized as one of the fastest-growing Fintech markets globally, sharing the highest FinTech adoption rate with China.
2. Digital Payments: The digital payments sector in India exhibited substantial growth, with a value of $65 billion in 2019. It is expected to continue growing at a CAGR of 20% until 2023.
3. Market Size: The overall transaction value in the Indian Fintech market is projected to increase from $65 billion in 2019 to $140 billion in 2023.
4. Fintech Companies: India boasts around 1,250 Fintech firms, contributing to job creation and attracting significant investments.

Regulatory Perspective:

1. Reserve Bank’s Role: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has actively encouraged the use of electronic payments to move towards a “less-cash” society.
2. Objectives:
   • Safety: Ensuring secure payment transactions.
   • Convenience: Enhancing the convenience of financial services.
   • Accessibility: Making financial services accessible to a broader population.
   • Technological Solutions: Leveraging technology for faster processing.
   • Affordability: Ensuring cost-effective financial solutions.
   • Interoperability: Facilitating seamless interaction between different systems.
   • Customer Awareness and Protection: Educating and safeguarding customers in the digital financial space.

Conclusion: Fintech in India represents a transformative force in the financial sector, offering innovative solutions that align with the country’s goals of universal financial inclusion. The growth of digital payments and the vibrant Fintech ecosystem underscore the significant progress made in the Indian financial landscape. Regulatory initiatives aim to balance innovation with safety, accessibility, and consumer protection.

New Technology Transforming Payment Services in India

Traditionally, banks held a monopoly on payment services. However, the rapid evolution of technology has disrupted this landscape, opening the door for non-bank entities to play a significant role in the payments domain. These non-bank entities collaborate and compete with banks, either by providing technology services to banks or by directly offering retail electronic payment services. Regulatory frameworks have adapted to encourage increased participation of non-bank entities in the evolving payments ecosystem.

The transition from Cash to Digital: Facilitators

1. Dominance of Cash: Cash has long been the dominant and widely used payment instrument due to its pervasiveness, ease of use, and convenience.
2. Rapid Increase in Digital Payments: Encouragingly, digital payments, especially those using electronic modes, have been rapidly gaining traction. The digital revolution, marked by technological metamorphosis, has transformed the payment and settlement systems globally.
3. Consumer Options: Consumers now have a plethora of options for completing transactions, ranging from traditional methods to a myriad of digital alternatives.
4. Wireless Telephony: As of November 2019, India had over 115.5 crore wireless telephone subscribers, with a tele-density of 88.90%. The proliferation of smartphones has accelerated the adoption of digital payments.
5. Smartphone Innovations: Smartphone usage has led to innovations such as tokenization and QR code scanning for payments. Tokenization enhances safety and security by replacing actual card details with a unique token.
6. Internet Penetration: Internet usage has surged in India, with an increasing focus on mobile data services. By November 2019, there were over 64.2 crore wireless and 1.9 crore wireline broadband subscribers in the country.
7. Digital Revolution Threshold: The growth of infrastructure, especially in terms of mobile cellular subscriptions and the expansion of 3G and 4G networks even in remote areas, marks a threshold for the “Digital Revolution” in India.

Conclusion: The dynamic shift from cash to digital payments in India is propelled by advancements in technology, increased internet penetration, and the widespread use of smartphones. The collaborative efforts of traditional banks and non-bank entities, coupled with a supportive regulatory framework, are steering the nation toward a digitally inclusive financial landscape.

Institutional Innovation and Regulatory Developments in Payments

In recent years, India has witnessed a concerted effort to establish a cutting-edge national payments infrastructure and technological platforms. Several transformative initiatives, including Immediate Payments Service (IMPS), Unified Payments Interface (UPI), Bharat Interface for Money (BHIM), Bharat Bill PaySystem (BBPS), and Aadhaar-enabled Payment System (AePS, have been introduced. These innovations have significantly reshaped the landscape of retail payments in the country, resulting in a substantial increase in the volume of retail electronic payments.

Key Developments:

1. Immediate Payments Service (IMPS): IMPS has played a pivotal role in enabling instant electronic payments, contributing to the evolution of retail transactions.
2. Unified Payments Interface (UPI): UPI has emerged as a versatile and user-friendly platform, facilitating seamless fund transfers and payments.
3. Bharat Interface for Money (BHIM): BHIM has provided a simplified and unified interface for making digital payments, enhancing accessibility for users.
4. Bharat Bill PaySystem (BBPS): BBPS has streamlined the bill payment process, offering a comprehensive and interoperable platform.
5. Aadhaar-enabled Payment System (AePS): AePS leverages Aadhaar authentication to enable financial transactions, fostering financial inclusion.

Performance Metrics:

1. NEFT System: In 2017-18, the NEFT system handled a staggering 195 crore transactions valued at approximately Rs. 172 lakh crore, showcasing a significant increase in both volume and value.
2. Card Transactions: The number of transactions through credit cards and debit cards in 2017-18 reached 141 crore and 334 crore, respectively, demonstrating the widespread adoption of card-based payments.
3. Prepaid Payment Instruments (PPIs): PPIs recorded around 346 crore transactions valued at Rs. 1.4 lakh crore, highlighting the popularity of digital wallets and prepaid instruments.
4. Total Card Payments: Card payments, encompassing credit and debit cards, accounted for 52 percent of total retail payments during the fiscal year 2017-18 in terms of volume.

Conclusion: India’s commitment to advancing its payments infrastructure and embracing technological innovations has resulted in a significant shift towards digital transactions. The adoption of various payment systems and the proliferation of electronic modes of payment underscore the transformative journey toward a more inclusive and efficient financial ecosystem. Regulatory support and institutional innovations have been instrumental in driving these positive changes in the retail payments landscape.

Alternative Models in FinTech and Trade Finance

In the realms of banking technology and trade finance, notable developments have emerged, paving the way for alternative models of lending and capital raising. These alternative models have the potential to reshape traditional market dynamics and the role of intermediaries.

1. Crowd-funding: This involves raising external finance from a large group of investors. While at a nascent stage in India, crowd-funding holds the potential to transform traditional financing methods.
2. Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Lending: P2P lending is positioned to enhance access to finance for small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Eleven entities have been licensed to operate P2P platforms, providing a new avenue for lending and borrowing.
3. Digital Loan Companies: Seven purely digital loan companies have received licenses from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). These companies operate through mobile applications, showcasing the integration of technology in the lending space.
4. Payment Banks: Seven payment banks have commenced operations, leveraging FinTech for customer onboarding and operational processes. These technology-led banks represent a digital approach to traditional banking services.
5. Invoice Trading: This emerging FinTech application aids MSMEs facing working capital and cash flow challenges due to delayed payments. It provides a platform for trading invoices and managing cash flows.
6. Trade Receivables Discounting System (TReDS): TReDS is an innovative financing arrangement facilitated by the RBI. It leverages technology for discounting bills and invoices. Three entities have been authorized, and the volumes are gradually gaining traction.
7. Account Aggregators (AA): A regulatory framework for Account Aggregators has been established, with five entities receiving in-principle approval as NBFC-AAs. This new form of NBFC aims to enhance digital payments and financial inclusion.

Regulatory Framework: To address the challenges and risks associated with the FinTech revolution, the RBI has established a regulatory framework. A five-member committee, chaired by Shri Nandan Nilekani, has been appointed to further deepen digital payments and enhance financial inclusion through FinTech. Early recognition of risks and proactive measures are deemed essential to harness the full potential of these developments.

The evolving landscape of alternative models in FinTech and trade finance reflects a dynamic shift in how financial services are conceptualized and delivered, with technology playing a central role in driving innovation.

Risks and Regulatory Technologies (RegTech) in Financial Inclusion

Achieving financial inclusion involves designing tailored financial products, digital onboarding, and increasing investments. Leveraging the Aadhaar ecosystem can incentivize people to adopt digital platforms, similar to the success seen in direct benefits transfer (DBT). The establishment of a central KYC registry is a significant step, with around 100 million KYC records already uploaded. Multi-lingual financial literacy and a robust grievance redressal mechanism are crucial to address regional disparities and offer online dispute resolutions.

Risk Mitigation through RegTech and SupTech:

1. RegTech (Regulatory Technology): Focuses on making regulatory compliance more efficient through automated processes, reducing compliance costs.
2. SupTech (Supervisory Technology): Supports supervisory agencies by using innovative technology to enhance supervision. The BIS defines SupTech as the use of technology for seamless data collection/reporting, analysis, streamlined licensing, market monitoring, and surveillance.

The Reserve Bank has implemented SupTech for data collection and analysis, evident in systems like Import Data Processing and Monitoring System (IDPMS), Export Data Processing and Monitoring System (EDPMS), and Central Repository of Information on Large Credits (CRILC). Risk-based supervision, extensively data-driven, exemplifies the application of SupTech.

Future of RegTech and SupTech: These technologies’ future lies in advanced tools like big data analytics, artificial intelligence, machine learning, cloud computing, GIS mapping, data transfer protocols, and biometrics. A transparent, technology-driven approach is essential. A strong risk culture, embedded in daily banking operations, is crucial for detecting, assessing, and mitigating emerging risks.

Systemic Risks and Data Concerns:

1. Systemic Risks: May arise from unsustainable credit growth, increased interconnectedness, procyclicality, development of new activities beyond supervisory frameworks, and financial risks associated with lower profitability.
2. Data Confidentiality and Customer Protection: Critical areas needing attention to ensure trust in the financial system.

Encouraging FinTech Alliances: The Reserve Bank encourages banks to form alliances with FinTech firms to accelerate financial inclusion through innovation. Unimpeded investments in this sector are crucial for realizing its full potential. Creating an ecosystem that promotes collaboration while considering macroeconomic implications is imperative.

Regulatory Sandbox in FinTech

To ensure the orderly development of FinTech, streamline their integration into the financial system, and safeguard stakeholders’ interests, a robust regulatory and supervisory framework is essential. The Reserve Bank’s working group on FinTech and digital banking in 2017 recommended the establishment of a ‘regulatory sandbox/innovation hub.’ This space, defined in terms of scope and duration, allows experimentation with FinTech solutions, with the ability to contain and analyze the consequences of failure.

Benefits of a Regulatory Sandbox:

1. Reduced Time to Launch: FinTech companies benefit from quicker launches of innovative products.
2. Lower Costs: The sandbox environment reduces the costs associated with testing and implementing innovative solutions.

The Reserve Bank plans to establish a regulatory sandbox, with guidelines expected to be issued in the next two months.

Balancing Innovation and Systemic Impact: Striking a delicate balance is crucial—leveraging FinTech effectively while minimizing potential systemic impacts. Enabling technologies and managing associated risks can contribute to creating a new financial system that is more inclusive, cost-effective, and resilient. This approach ensures that FinTech innovations are integrated safely and efficiently into the financial landscape. 

FAQs

1. What is the promise of fintech in India?

• Fintech in India promises financial inclusion by providing access to banking and financial services to the unbanked and underbanked populations.
• It offers convenience through digital payments, reducing the reliance on cash transactions and increasing financial efficiency.
• Fintech fosters innovation by leveraging technology to develop new financial products and services tailored to diverse consumer needs.
• It enhances transparency and security in financial transactions, bolstering trust among users and stakeholders.
• Fintech promotes economic growth by facilitating easier access to credit for individuals and small businesses, fostering entrepreneurship and job creation.

2. What progress has fintech made in India?

• Fintech adoption has surged, with a growing number of Indians using digital payment platforms, mobile wallets, and online banking services.
• India’s Unified Payments Interface (UPI) has emerged as a global benchmark, enabling seamless peer-to-peer and peer-to-merchant transactions.
• The rise of fintech startups has spurred innovation in areas such as lending, insurance, wealth management, and personal finance management.
• Collaboration between traditional financial institutions and fintech firms has accelerated, leading to the development of hybrid financial services models.
• Government initiatives like the Jan Dhan Yojana, Aadhaar, and GST have facilitated fintech growth by providing a robust digital infrastructure and regulatory support.

3. How is fintech driving innovation in India?

• Fintech innovations like AI-driven credit scoring, blockchain-based remittance, and robo-advisors are revolutionizing traditional financial services.
• Digital lending platforms are leveraging alternative data sources to extend credit to underserved segments, including gig workers and MSMEs.
• Insurtech startups are introducing innovative insurance products and distribution channels, making insurance more accessible and affordable.
• Wealthtech platforms are democratizing investment opportunities by offering low-cost, personalized investment solutions to retail investors.
• Fintech innovations in payment technology, including QR codes, NFC, and contactless payments, are transforming the retail and e-commerce sectors.

4. What are the regulatory challenges facing fintech in India?

• Regulatory uncertainty and ambiguity hinder fintech innovation and investment, leading to compliance burdens and operational challenges.
• Fragmented regulatory oversight across different financial sectors creates regulatory arbitrage and inconsistencies in regulatory treatment.
• Data privacy and cybersecurity concerns pose significant challenges, requiring robust regulations to safeguard consumer data and mitigate cyber risks.
• Regulatory barriers to entry, such as high capital requirements and licensing fees, deter startups and hinder competition in the fintech sector.
• Regulatory sandbox frameworks and fintech accelerators are emerging as solutions to foster innovation while ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements.

5. How is India addressing regulatory challenges in fintech?

• The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has introduced regulatory sandboxes and innovation hubs to provide a controlled environment for fintech experimentation.
• Regulatory reforms, such as the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007, and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, aim to strengthen the legal and regulatory framework for fintech.
• Collaborative initiatives between regulators, industry stakeholders, and academia are fostering dialogue and promoting regulatory coherence in the fintech ecosystem.
• The Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, aims to establish a comprehensive framework for data protection and privacy, addressing concerns related to data security and consumer privacy.
• International cooperation and alignment with global regulatory standards help India maintain regulatory competitiveness and promote cross-border fintech innovation and collaboration.

In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901. 

For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here

For Daily Updates and Study Material:

Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS

• 1. Learn through Videos – here
• 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
• 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
• 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here

Visit our YouTube Channel – here