Introduction:
The Vice President of India serves as the ceremonial Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and can act as the acting President in their absence. The U.S. Vice President presides over the Senate, advises the President, and assumes the presidency if the President is unable, showing the diverse roles of VPs in various nations due to distinct political systems and historical backgrounds.
Body:Â Â
The role and responsibilities of the India Vice President compared with the USA Vice President:
| Aspect | India Vice President | USA Vice President |
| Constitutional Position | Article 63 of the Indian Constitution establishes the Office of the Vice President of India. | The Vice Presidency of the United States is established by Article II, Section 1 of the U.S. Constitution. |
| Presiding Over the Legislature | Article 64 of the Indian Constitution designates the Vice President as the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, presiding over its sessions, maintaining order, and casting tie-breaking votes when necessary. | The U.S. Constitution (Article I, Section 3) designates the Vice President as the President of the Senate, presiding over Senate sessions and casting tie-breaking votes when required. |
| Succession to the Presidency | Article 65 of the Indian Constitution states that in the event of the President’s absence, resignation, or death, the Vice President assumes the role of Acting President until a new President is elected or the incumbent returns. | The 25th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution clarifies the process for the Vice President to assume the role of President in case of the President’s death, resignation, or incapacity. |
| Advisor to the President | While not constitutionally mandated, the Vice President often serves as an advisor to the President, providing counsel on various policy matters. | The Vice President of the United States is a significant advisor to the President, offering guidance on policy decisions, legislative matters, and executive assignments. |
| Official Representation | The Vice President represents India in official functions and ceremonies, both domestically and internationally, in line with the President’s directions. | The U.S. Vice President represents the United States in both domestic and international events, reinforcing diplomatic ties and showcasing the country’s commitments. |
Challenges for the Vice President of India:
- Ceremonial Role: Primarily serving as the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, the Vice President of India may find their influence constrained, limiting their involvement in policy and governance matters.
- Limited Executive Power: In contrast to the U.S. counterpart, the Indian Vice President possesses minimal executive authority and seldom assumes the acting President’s role.
- Maintaining Neutrality: Navigating a politically charged environment, the apolitical nature of the position requires the Indian Vice President to stay neutral in parliamentary proceedings, posing a unique challenge.
Challenges for the Vice President of the USA:
- Dynamic Role: Juggling diverse responsibilities, including presiding over the Senate, advising the President, and being the immediate successor, demands the U.S. Vice President to adeptly balance these dynamic roles.
- Partisan Politics: Operating within a highly partisan atmosphere, the U.S. Vice President faces challenges in managing politically sensitive issues while pursuing their own policy objectives.
- Legislative Influence: As the President of the Senate, the U.S. Vice President encounters the challenge of casting tie-breaking votes and collaborating with Senators from both parties to advance the President’s legislative agenda, particularly in a divided Congress.
Conclusion:
In essence, the roles and challenges of Vice Presidents in India and the United States markedly differ, reflecting the distinct political systems and historical trajectories of the two nations. The U.S. Vice President holds a more substantial constitutional and practical authority compared to their Indian counterpart.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
