Isostasy is a foundational concept in geomorphology and Earth interior studies, frequently asked in UPSC GS-1 and Geography Optional. While most questions focus on Airy and Pratt, Arthur Holmes’ isostasy theory is crucial because it connects classical isostasy with modern plate tectonics.
Contents
What is Isostasy?
Isostasy refers to the state of gravitational equilibrium between the Earth’s crust and the underlying mantle.
It explains:
- Why mountains do not collapse under their own weight
- How landforms adjust to erosion, deposition, loading, and unloading
- How the crust maintains balance over geological time
In simple terms, isostasy is about vertical balance of the lithosphere.
Classical Isostasy Theories: Airy vs Pratt (Quick Revision)
Airy’s Theory of Isostasy (Flotation Theory)
- Assumes uniform density of crust
- Topographic differences compensated by roots
- Higher mountains → deeper roots
- No common depth of compensation
Pratt’s Theory of Isostasy (Density Compensation Theory)
- Assumes variable density
- Equal masses under equal areas
- Introduces a common plane of compensation
- Emphasises material differences rather than flotation
UPSC expects you to mention both, even when the question is on Arthur Holmes.
Arthur Holmes Isostasy Theory: Core Idea
Arthur Holmes (1920s–30s) revisited isostasy with a much better understanding of:
- Earth’s interior
- Mantle behaviour
- Thermal and material dynamics
His theory is best understood as a modification of Airy’s model, enriched by mantle dynamics and partially borrowing from Pratt’s logic.
Key Postulates of Arthur Holmes’ Isostasy Theory
1. Support for Airy’s Flotation Concept
- Holmes agreed that Airy’s root-based model is fundamentally correct
- Taller mountains possess deeper crustal roots
- Plateaus have shallower roots; oceans have the shallowest
2. Introduction of Mohorovičić Discontinuity (Moho)
- When the bases of all crustal roots are joined, they form the Moho
- Moho marks the boundary between crust and mantle
- This was a major conceptual advance absent in Airy and Pratt
3. Common Depth of Density Normalisation (~50 km)
- Holmes accepted that density variations disappear at a certain depth
- Placed this depth at ~50 km, unlike Pratt–Hayford–Bowie (~100 km)
- Though not explicitly called “compensation depth,” the concept exists
4. Role of Mantle Dynamism
- Holmes added mantle convection and material flow
- Loading causes crustal sinking; unloading leads to isostatic rebound
- Mantle material adjusts dynamically to maintain equilibrium
This makes isostasy an active process, not a static condition.
Arthur Holmes as a Bridge Theory
Arthur Holmes’ contribution is crucial because:
- He links Airy’s flotation theory with mantle dynamics
- His ideas are later absorbed into plate tectonics
- Modern understanding attributes isostatic balance to asthenospheric flow
Hence, Holmes’ theory acts as a conceptual bridge between classical isostasy and plate tectonics interpretation of isostasy.
How to Write This in UPSC Mains
A high-scoring structure:
- Define isostasy
- Briefly explain Airy and Pratt
- Introduce Arthur Holmes as a modifier
- Mention Moho + mantle dynamism + 50 km depth
- Conclude with link to plate tectonics
Diagrams of roots, Moho, and compensation significantly boost marks.
Check out our GS Geography Course – Click Here
FAQs
- #ArthurHolmesIsostasy: What is Arthur Holmes’ theory of isostasy?
- #IsostasyUPSC: How does Arthur Holmes modify Airy and Pratt theories of isostasy?
- #MohoDiscontinuity: What is the role of Moho discontinuity in Arthur Holmes’ isostasy theory?
- #PlateTectonicsIsostasy: How is Arthur Holmes’ isostasy theory linked to plate tectonics?
