India’s evolving stance on the Israel-Palestine issue reflects a delicate diplomatic balancing act. Traditionally, India has maintained strong ties with the Palestinian cause, rooted in historical solidarity and support for the Palestinian right to self-determination. However, in recent years, there has been a noticeable shift with India cultivating closer relations with Israel, driven by shared interests in areas such as defense, technology, and counter-terrorism. This nuanced approach underscores India’s pragmatic foreign policy, navigating the complexities of the Middle East while pursuing its national interests. The challenge lies in maintaining equilibrium, as the geopolitical landscape continues to shape India’s position on this longstanding and sensitive matter.
Tag: GS-2 International Relations
Exam View
History of India-Israel Relationships; Recent Shifts of India’s foreign policy; India’s stand on the Israel-Palestine conflict
Context
India’s response to the Hamas attack in Israel has been unambiguous. India has condemned the terror attack and expressed solidarity with Israel moving away from its long held stance of neutrality.
History of India-Israel Relationships
- Post Independence Stance: India firmly backed the Palestinian cause, with leaders like Nehru and Gandhi advocating against religious exclusivism.
- In UN decisions, India opposed the division of Palestine and the entry of Israel into the UN. However, India acknowledged Israel in 1950, following Turkey and Iran’s recognition.
- Strengthening Bonds with Palestine: Under Indira Gandhi’s leadership, India remained steadfast in backing the Palestinian cause, endorsing the PLO as Palestine’s only legitimate voice..
- Evolution of India-Israel Ties in the 1990s: India established full diplomatic ties with Israel in 1992, influenced by the end of the Cold War and BJP’s ascendancy. The bilateral relationship further solidified in 1999 when Israel aided India during the Kargil conflict.
- Balancing Israel and West Asia: India’s foreign policy has adeptly managed India’s relations with both Israel and Palestine, evidenced by separate visits in 2017 and 2018 respectively.
Recent Shifts of India’s foreign policy
- Acknowledgement of India-Israel Relationship: India’s foreign policy shifted towards openly embracing India’s ties with Israel, breaking from traditional hesitations.
- Realignment Towards Ground Realities: The current government recognizes that many Arab nations are forming relations with Israel without prior conditions. However India still officially backs the two-state solution for Israel-Palestine.
- Strengthening Ties with the Arab World: Despite earlier regimes claiming to support Arab causes, the current foreign policy has strengthened and modernised India’s relations with major Arab nations, making UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt key strategic allies.
- Abandonment of the Anti-Western Stand: The current government moved away from India’s traditional resistance to the West’s role in the Middle East, partnering with countries like the US, Israel, and UAE in new alliances and initiatives such as I2U2.
- Diplomacy Beyond Religion: A major shift has been the separation of India’s regional diplomacy from religious considerations. While India has benefited from pragmatic ties with the Arab world, religious-based diplomacy has not been as beneficial for Pakistan.
India’s stand on the Israel-Palestine conflict
- Support for a Two-State Solution: India supports a negotiated solution leading to a sovereign, independent, viable, and united State of Palestine coexisting peacefully with Israel.
- Maintained Relations with Both Parties: India has diplomatic relations with both Israel and Palestine, which reflects its balanced approach to the Middle East conflict.
- Condemnation of Violence: India condemns all acts of violence, especially against civilians.
- Emphasis on Dialogue: India emphasizes the importance of dialogue for lasting peace and reconciliation.
- Historical Ties with Palestine: India has traditionally supported the Palestinian cause at international forums.
- Deepening Ties with Israel: Over the past couple of decades, India and Israel have cultivated strong bilateral relations, especially in areas of defence, agriculture, and technology.
- Call for immediate cessation of violence and de-escalation of the situation.
- Protection of civilians on both sides: India calls for safeguarding the rights of civilians on both sides of the border.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Why has India’s stance on the Israel-Palestine issue changed in recent years?
A1: India’s evolving stance is driven by a pragmatic approach to foreign policy. The shift is influenced by shared interests with Israel in areas such as defense, technology, and counter-terrorism, while maintaining historical solidarity with the Palestinian cause.
Q2: Does India still support the Palestinian cause despite growing ties with Israel?
A2: Yes, India reaffirms its support for the Palestinian cause and the two-state solution. The evolving relations with Israel do not negate India’s commitment to the principles of justice and the right to self-determination for the Palestinian people.
Q3: How does India balance its relationships with Israel and Arab nations given the historical tensions in the Middle East?
A3: India pursues a balanced and nuanced approach, engaging with both Israel and Arab nations. This involves maintaining traditional ties with the Arab world while fostering strategic partnerships with Israel, demonstrating India’s ability to navigate complex geopolitical dynamics.
Q4: What specific areas of cooperation exist between India and Israel that contribute to the changing stance?
A4: India and Israel collaborate in defense, technology, agriculture, and counter-terrorism. These partnerships have strengthened over the years, influencing India’s stance on the Israel-Palestine issue as shared interests take precedence in diplomatic decision-making.
Q5: How does India address concerns about human rights violations in the Israel-Palestine conflict while expanding ties with Israel?
A5: India maintains that addressing human rights concerns is crucial, and it consistently advocates for a peaceful resolution to the Israel-Palestine conflict. Diplomatically, India engages with both parties, encouraging dialogue and a just, lasting solution that respects the rights and aspirations of all involved.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
