The search for meaning and the existence of a divine being have long been fundamental questions in the realm of philosophy. In the context of the UPSC Mains examination, the Philosophy optional paper is a challenging yet thought-provoking subject, and one of its intriguing topics is “Proofs for the Existence of God and their Critique.” This area of study delves into the complex arguments and counterarguments put forth by philosophers throughout history, exploring various attempts to provide rational and logical support for the belief in a higher power. In this blog series, we will embark on a journey through a decade of UPSC Mains Philosophy optional questions on this topic, spanning from 2013 to 2023. By examining these questions and their evolving trends, we aim to equip aspiring civil servants with a comprehensive understanding of this intricate subject, helping them tackle the nuances of these philosophical inquiries effectively in their examinations.
Over the years, the UPSC has consistently tested the philosophical acumen of candidates by delving into the timeless discourse on God’s existence. These questions challenge candidates to critically assess the classical and contemporary arguments made by prominent philosophers and offer their own nuanced perspectives. Through this blog series, we will dissect the questions asked by UPSC, explore the philosophical underpinnings, and provide insightful critiques of the arguments presented. Whether you’re an aspiring civil servant with Philosophy as your optional subject or simply someone intrigued by the profound questions of existence, this series promises to be a fascinating exploration of the philosophical debates surrounding the divine, offering valuable insights into the world of UPSC examinations and the enduring quest for answers about God’s existence.
Proofs for the Existence of God and their Critique Philosophy – Previous Year Questions (UPSC CSE Mains History Optional)
1. Compare and contrast the different forms of cosmological arguments for the existence of God. (2017/15)
2. Is existence of Goda necessary condition for the survival of religion?Explain.(2015/10)
3. Examine the Nyaya arguments in favour of the existence of God.(2015/20)
4. Examine the ontological and cosmological arguments in favour of existence of God.(2015/15)
5. Discuss the ontological argument for the existence of God ,and show its merits and demerits. (2014/15)
6. Can it self-contradictory to accept the idea of God but deny the existence of God ?(2014/15)
7. State and elucidate cosmological argument for the existence of god in Western and Indian philosophy . (2013/15)
8. Discuss two main objections against this argument . Are theist able to answer these satisfactorily. (2013/15)
9. Critically evaluate three main objections against the argument from design for the existence of god . (2013/20)
10. Can God’s existence be proved with cogent and convincing rational arguments ? (2012/12)
11. Why is a proof for the existence of God necessary for the growth of a religion? Discuss. 2011 /15 marks
12. Is contingent argument for the existence of God anything more than a logical exercise? Discuss. 10/20
13. If each and every argument has to take that its premises are true, would the causal argument for the existence of God as the first cause be different from assuming that it is true? Argue in favour of your position. 10/20
14. Human mind is such that it naturally observes order in nature. Given this can one use arguments from design for the existence of God? Discuss. 10/20.
15. Critically examine the causal argument as a proof for the existence of God. 09/20.
16. Analyse the teleological argument as a proof for the existence of God. 09/30
17. Different versions of ontological arguments and Kant’s critique of these arguments. Critical note. 08/20
18. State and evaluate the cosmological argument for the existence of God. What are its two forms? What is the difference between adependent being and self-existent being? Why is the self-existent being theo-centric? Can the nature itself be conceived as self-existent being? Discuss. 07/60
19. State and evaluate the cosmological argument for the existence of God. What are its two forms? What is the difference between adependent being and self-existent being? Why is the self-existent being theo-centric? Can the nature itself be conceived as self-existent being? Discuss. 06/60.20.
20. “God is the first reason of things.” Critical notes. 05/20
21. “If God exists only in someone’s mind, the greatest conceivablebeing is not after all the greatest conceivable being.” Critical notes.05/20.
22. Some theists question the relevancy of proofs and arguments fortheistic beliefs. Believers in their view are not irrational for want ofproof for their belief in God because proofs are neither necessarynor sufficient for religious life. Would you agree with such a view?Discuss.
23. Is the ontological argument for the existence of God really invalid?Critical notes.
24. Do any of these received proofs for the existence of God succeed inproving God’s existence? Discuss. In this context, critically considere specially the cosmological argument.
25. Ontological proof for the existence of God. Critical notes.
Q1: What are some classical arguments for the existence of God?
A1: Classical arguments for the existence of God include the Cosmological Argument, Teleological Argument, and the Ontological Argument. The Cosmological Argument posits that there must be a First Cause or Uncaused Cause behind the universe. The Teleological Argument asserts that the order and complexity in the universe imply a purposeful Creator. The Ontological Argument, proposed by philosophers like Anselm and Descartes, argues for God’s existence based on the concept of a perfect being.
Q2: How do philosophers critique these arguments for God’s existence?
A2: Philosophers critique these arguments in various ways. Some question the validity of the premises and whether they necessarily lead to the conclusion of God’s existence. Others raise objections related to the problem of evil, asking how the existence of a benevolent God can be reconciled with the presence of suffering in the world. Additionally, some philosophers challenge the use of human reason to prove the existence of a transcendent being.
Q3: What are some contemporary arguments for and against the existence of God?
A3: Contemporary arguments for God’s existence include the Kalam Cosmological Argument and the Fine-Tuning Argument, both of which draw upon modern scientific discoveries to support the idea of a Creator. On the opposing side, atheistic arguments often focus on naturalistic explanations for the universe’s origin and development, such as the Multiverse Hypothesis and the argument from biological evolution.
Q4: Can one prove or disprove God’s existence conclusively through philosophical arguments?
A4: Philosophical arguments on the existence of God are highly debated and subject to interpretation. They do not provide conclusive proof one way or the other. Belief in God is often a matter of faith and personal conviction, and these philosophical arguments may provide intellectual support but cannot definitively prove or disprove God’s existence.
Q5: How can I prepare for questions on Proofs for the Existence of God in the UPSC Philosophy optional paper?
A5: To prepare for such questions, study classical and contemporary arguments for and against God’s existence. Read the works of renowned philosophers like Aquinas, Kant, and Plantinga, and be familiar with atheistic perspectives as well. Practice constructing logical and coherent critiques of these arguments. Moreover, review past UPSC Mains question papers to understand the types of questions asked and the depth of analysis required, and consider seeking guidance from experienced mentors or educators in the field of philosophy.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here