AUKUS, uniting Australia, the UK, and the US, signals a robust response to China’s influence. While not replacing existing partnerships, it strengthens Western alliances in the Indo-Pacific, bolstering security capabilities and technology sharing. The pact’s impact hinges on effective coordination and managing regional dynamics.
UPSC Mains General Studies Paper – 2 Mains 2021
UPSC Mains Civil Services IAS Exam Question Paper – 2021
Approach
- Start with briefly explaining the tri nation partnership AUKUS and how it is aimed at countering China in the Indo-Pacific region.
- Discuss if it will supersede the existing partnerships like Quad in the region .
- Discuss the strength and impact of AUKUS in the present scenario.
- Conclude accordingly.
Answer
Introduction
- The leaders of Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States recently unveiled the establishment of a trilateral security pact named AUKUS. This nuclear coalition has sparked significant anger from France. During the announcement, the US President indirectly referenced China, stating the need to address rapidly evolving threats. As part of the pact, the US and UK will collaborate with Australia in sharing intelligence and advanced technologies, including artificial intelligence, cyber warfare, quantum computing, and the construction of nuclear submarines.
Body
Supersede the existing partnerships in the Indo-Pacific region: A new partnership or alliance will supersede the Quad in the region, needing more specific information about the nature and objectives of this hypothetical alliance.
- Geopolitical Dynamics: The geopolitical landscape is complex, and alliances and partnerships often evolve based on changing dynamics. While it’s possible for new partnerships to emerge, it is unlikely that a single alliance would completely supersede the Quad. Existing partnerships, like the Quad, have already established frameworks, mechanisms, and a certain degree of trust among member countries.
- Complementary Objectives: Any new partnership would need to have clear and complementary objectives that differentiate it from existing alliances. The Quad primarily focuses on security cooperation, maritime security, and economic collaboration. If a new partnership were to emerge, it would need to address different or additional aspects of regional cooperation to effectively differentiate itself from the Quad.
- Regional Consensus: The success and relevance of any partnership in the region depend on the willingness of countries to participate and the broader regional consensus. The Quad has received both support and criticism from various countries in the region. A new partnership would need to garner substantial support and involvement from key regional players to supersede or significantly impact the Quad.
- Overlapping Memberships: It’s worth noting that countries involved in existing partnerships, such as the Quad, may also participate in other regional groupings or alliances. For example, some Quad members are also part of ASEAN-led frameworks. Overlapping memberships can create complexities and influence the potential for a new partnership to supersede existing alliances.
The strength and impact of AUKUS in the present scenario: its potential strength and impact can be analysed based on the capabilities and interests of the participating countries.
1. Strengths
- Enhanced Defence Capabilities: AUKUS seeks to strengthen the defence capabilities of Australia by providing it with nuclear-powered submarines. These submarines can offer increased endurance, stealth, and advanced technological capabilities, which could bolster Australia’s naval force and its ability to project power in the region.
- Technological Cooperation: AUKUS intends to facilitate technology sharing and collaboration among the partner countries. This cooperation can lead to advancements in areas such as artificial intelligence, cyber capabilities, and quantum technologies, bolstering each country’s defence capabilities and technological edge.
- Deterrent Signal: The formation of AUKUS sends a strong deterrent signal to potential adversaries in the Indo-Pacific region. By aligning with the UK and the US, Australia gains access to the collective military capabilities and diplomatic influence of these partners, which may discourage aggressive actions or adventurism in the region.
- Strengthening Alliances: These include the groundbreaking Indo-US Civil Nuclear Agreement signed in 2008, the establishment of the Defence Technology and Trade Initiative in 2012, the recognition of India as a “Major Defence Partner” by the US Congress in 2016, the granting of Tier 1 status to India allowing for the export of high-technology items, and the initiation of “2+2 talks” in 2018. The signing of the fourth and final “foundational agreement” in 2020 was expected to remove the last obstacle to further enhance defence cooperation between the two nations.
2. Impact
- Regional Power Dynamics: AUKUS has the potential to impact the existing power dynamics in the Indo-Pacific region. The enhanced defence capabilities of Australia, particularly in the maritime domain, could influence the strategic calculus of other regional actors and prompt them to reassess their own military strategies and partnerships.
- Implications for Non-Proliferation Efforts: AUKUS involves the transfer of nuclear propulsion technology to Australia. This development has raised questions and concerns about its implications for global non-proliferation efforts and the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). The agreement will need to address these concerns and ensure that it does not undermine the broader non-proliferation regime.
- Impact on Existing Partnerships: AUKUS may have implications for existing partnerships and alliances in the Indo-Pacific region. It could potentially affect the dynamics within the Quad, a strategic dialogue among Australia, the US, Japan, and India, as well as other regional arrangements and partnerships. Balancing commitments and priorities among various partnerships will be essential to maintain stability and cooperation in the region.
- Impact on India: The establishment of AUKUS is aimed at delivering a more forceful message to China, yet China’s characterization of this alliance as an “exclusionary bloc” raises important considerations for India and Japan, two members of the Quad/Malabar forums, who find themselves excluded from this new coalition.
Conclusion
- Hence, In the present scenario, AUKUS represents a significant development in countering China’s ambitions in the Indo-Pacific. However, the complex and ever-changing nature of regional dynamics necessitates a nuanced and adaptive approach to partnerships and alliances in the region. AUKUS brings unique strengths and impacts by enhancing military capabilities and sending a deterrent message to China. However, it also poses challenges and risks that need to be carefully managed to ensure regional stability and inclusiveness in the long run.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
