To enhance the capacity of the Indian state, a multifaceted approach is imperative, encompassing reforms in governance, administration, and strategic planning. Strengthening institutional frameworks, streamlining bureaucratic processes, and fostering a culture of efficiency are pivotal steps. Embracing technological advancements and leveraging data-driven decision-making can significantly boost the state’s effectiveness. Additionally, investing in education and skill development for public servants is crucial for adapting to evolving challenges. Furthermore, fostering a transparent and accountable system, coupled with citizen engagement, can bridge the gap between the government and the governed. Ultimately, a holistic transformation is essential, addressing both structural deficiencies and promoting a dynamic, responsive state apparatus capable of meeting the diverse needs of a rapidly evolving society.
Tag: GS- 2 Issues Relating to Development, Executive
In News:
It is pertinent to delves into the paradoxical nature of the Indian state, contending with the dual challenge of its expansive reach while encountering limitations in its capacity.
Comparing the Indian State with Others
- The scale of the Weberian state in India is notably compact.
- Within the G-20 group, it holds the distinction of having the fewest civil servants per capita.
- India’s public sector’s contribution to overall employment, standing at 5.77%, is only half of what is observed in Indonesia and China and approximately one-third of the figure in the United Kingdom.
- In terms of central government personnel, India trails significantly with approximately 1,600 per million, a stark contrast to the 7,500 in the United States.
- Moreover, across various professions—doctors, teachers, town planners, police, judges, firefighters, inspectors for food and drugs, and regulators—the per capita figures in India are the lowest even when compared to countries at a similar stage of development.
Challenges Facing the Indian State
Outsourcing Services due to Inadequate State Capability
- The Indian state, with relatively small metrics like the tax-GDP and public expenditure-GDP ratios, faces challenges in providing public goods, welfare payments, and justice system services due to scarcity rather than surplus.
- As a result, essential services like primary health are often outsourced.
Perverse Incentives and Skill Gap
- Perverse incentives within public institutions and a skill gap among officials hamper the ability of political executives and civil services to formulate and implement sound policies.
Extreme Concentration of Powers
- Policy-making and implementation powers are extremely concentrated in India, fostering a culture of mistrust and reducing accountability for poor implementation due to restrictions on frontline personnel.
Technocratic Gap
- Top policymakers lack technocratic skills to manage the complexities of an increasingly sophisticated economy.
- As a result, consultancy firms are frequently hired by the Centre and States to address economic, financial, and technical matters.
Lack of Strength of Staff with Market Watchdogs
- Market watchdogs like SEBI and the RBI suffer from a shortage of professional staff.
- SEBI, for instance, has around 800 professionals compared to over 4,500 experts in the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
Weak Oversight and Audit Practices
- Narrowly scoped audits by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, along with hindsight-based decision-making by oversight agencies like the Central Vigilance Commission and the Central Bureau of Investigation, lead to delayed procurement and contractual disputes.
Problematic Appointment of Retired Officers
- The appointment of retired officers to regulatory bodies and tribunals poses challenges, making civil servants susceptible to political influence and compromising in-service decisions.
Reduced Efficacy of the Public Sector
- The political economy of the public sector undermines its efficacy, with performance-linked pay and incentive schemes proving less effective than in the private sector.
- The disproportionately high public sector salaries, especially after Pay Commissions, contribute to corruption and make government jobs excessively lucrative.
The Path Forward
Decouple Policymaking and Implementation
- Drawing lessons from countries like Australia, Malaysia, and the United Kingdom, segregating policymaking and implementation responsibilities accelerates execution and fosters innovation.
- The model of the National Highways Authority of India, where policy decisions are centralized, while execution is delegated, has proven effective in reducing delays and cost overruns.
Delegate Financial and Administrative Powers
- Breaking the cycle of poor delegation and deficient state capability involves empowering frontline functionaries or street-level bureaucrats with clearly defined financial and administrative powers.
- This approach can enhance efficiency.
Normalize the Lateral Entry Culture
- Incorporating a systematic and regular lateral entry mechanism at mid and senior levels can address the size and technocratic gap in civil services.
- Competent officers from non-IAS services should have equal opportunities for high-level positions, supported by subject-specific training under Mission Karmayogi.
Sensitize Regulatory Agencies
- To curb the default mode of appealing against arbitration and court awards, oversight agencies need sensitization to understand the context of policy decisions.
- Factors such as the costs associated with actual decisions and their alternatives should be considered.
Increase the Retirement Age
- Elevating the retirement age to 65 for all government jobs and establishing an absolute upper limit for appointments can mitigate susceptibility to political manipulation arising from the appointment of retired officers to regulatory bodies.
Reform Public Sector Employment
- Ensuring that the public sector attracts intrinsically motivated individuals requires aligning risk and skill-adjusted pay with job security and better working conditions.
- Modest pay raises by future Pay Commissions and a reduction in the upper age limit for government jobs are potential solutions.
Create Jobs in the Private Sector
- Promoting high economic growth to generate lucrative job opportunities in the private sector can diminish the allure of government jobs for financially motivated individuals.
- This shift has the potential to reduce corruption and attract socially-driven individuals to government service.
| UPSC Previous Year Questions Mains (2020) Q. “Institutional quality is a crucial driver of economic performance”. In this context suggest reforms in the Civil Service to strengthen democracy. |
Source: TH
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: What specific reforms are needed to enhance the capacity of the Indian state?
Answer: Structural reforms in governance, administrative processes, and strategic planning are essential. This includes strengthening institutions, embracing technology, and investing in education and skill development for public servants.
Q: How can technology contribute to enhancing the capacity of the Indian state?
Answer: Technology can play a pivotal role by facilitating data-driven decision-making, automating processes, and improving overall efficiency in government operations. This includes digitalizing services, implementing e-governance initiatives, and leveraging artificial intelligence for strategic planning.
Q: Why is citizen engagement considered crucial in enhancing the capacity of the Indian state?
Answer: Citizen engagement fosters transparency, accountability, and inclusivity in governance. By involving citizens in decision-making processes, the government can better understand and address the needs of the population, creating a more responsive and effective state.
Q: What challenges does the Indian state face in implementing capacity-enhancing reforms?
Answer: Challenges include bureaucratic inertia, resistance to change, and the need for substantial financial investments. Overcoming these hurdles requires comprehensive planning, effective communication, and a commitment to gradual but sustained transformation.
Q: How can the Indian state balance the need for efficiency with the imperative of inclusivity in capacity-building efforts?
Answer: Striking a balance involves tailoring policies to ensure that efficiency gains do not disproportionately affect marginalized groups. Inclusive education and skill development programs, along with targeted initiatives, can help ensure that capacity-building efforts benefit all sections of society.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here
