- Left-wing politics encompasses a range of political ideologies that prioritize achieving social equality and reject social hierarchies or class divisions. It refers to a collective of individuals, often affiliated with a political party, whose beliefs lean more towards socialism compared to other members of the party. The terms “left” and “right” originated during the 18th-century French Revolution. Examples of political parties associated with left-wing ideology include the Communist Party of India and the Democrats in the United States.
- During the late 1920s and 1930s in India, a significant left-wing movement emerged, playing a crucial role in radicalizing the national independence movement. The objective of achieving political independence gradually incorporated a stronger emphasis on social and economic issues. The paths of the struggle for national independence and the struggle for social and economic emancipation of the oppressed and exploited started to converge.
- Socialist ideas found fertile ground in India, and socialism became a widely embraced ideology among the Indian youth, who looked up to leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Chandra Bose as symbols of their aspirations. Over time, the Communist Party of India (CPI) and the Congress Socialist Party (CSP) emerged as influential left-wing political parties, with the CSP operating within the larger framework of the Indian National Congress.
- The CSP played a significant role in advocating for socialist principles and pushing for social and economic reforms within the national movement. Their efforts contributed to shaping the discourse and direction of the Indian struggle for independence, blending it with the pursuit of social justice and economic equality.
Concept of Left Wing
- The concept of left-wing politics revolves around liberal beliefs that advocate for a larger government role in society. Left-wing politics is characterized by its emphasis on equality, fraternity, development, and change. The term “left-wing” originated during the French Revolution, when those opposing the monarchy sat on the left side of the hall. Left-wing individuals encompass a diverse range of ideologies, including anarchists, communists, socialists, democratic socialists, social democrats, left-libertarians, progressives, and social liberals. Within left-wing nationalism, social equality, popular sovereignty, and national self-determination play central roles, often in association with national liberation movements. Left-wing politics generally maintains a critical stance towards religious organizations, advocating for the separation of state and religion (Secularism). Furthermore, it opposes social hierarchy and various forms of class divisions.
Opinion and Classification of the Left-wing
Opinion of the Left-wing
The left-wing perspective differs from right-wing politics primarily in terms of individual liberty and government power. Left-wing parties generally hold the following views or policies:
- Separation of religion and government: Left-wing parties tend to advocate for a clear separation between religious institutions and the government. They emphasize the importance of secularism and the autonomy of individuals in matters of faith.
- Support for same-sex marriage: Left-wing parties often promote equal rights and inclusivity, including supporting the legalization of same-sex marriage and advocating for LGBTQ+ rights.
- Opposition to the death penalty: Left-wing parties tend to oppose the use of the death penalty, focusing on rehabilitation and alternatives to capital punishment.
- Support for immigration: Left-wing parties generally favour more open and inclusive immigration policies, aiming to provide opportunities for immigrants and address humanitarian concerns.
- Higher taxes on the wealthy: Left-wing parties often propose higher tax rates on the wealthy as a means to redistribute wealth and reduce income inequality.
- Embrace of globalization: Left-wing parties generally support the idea of global interconnectedness and cooperation, recognizing the benefits of international collaboration in areas such as trade, environmental protection, and human rights.
- Striving for social equality: Left-wing parties prioritize reducing social inequalities and promoting equal opportunities for all members of society.
- Central planning: Left-wing parties may support greater government intervention and planning in economic affairs, aiming to regulate and address issues such as income disparities, worker protections, and market failures.
- Government interference in the economy: Left-wing parties often advocate for government intervention and regulation to safeguard workers’ rights, protect consumers, and ensure fair competition.
- Welfare state: Left-wing parties typically advocate for a robust welfare state, with social programs and safety nets aimed at providing support to vulnerable individuals and addressing societal inequalities.
- Critique of free trade: While not universally held by all left-wing parties, some express concerns about the impacts of free trade on workers’ rights, environmental sustainability, and domestic industries, advocating for fair trade policies.
It’s important to note that these viewpoints can vary among different left-wing parties and individuals, as ideologies and priorities can differ across countries and contexts.
Classification of Left-Wing
Left-wing ideologies can indeed be classified into two main groups based on their differing viewpoints:
Economically left and Socially left.
- Economically left: This refers to the stance taken by political parties or individuals who advocate for greater government intervention and regulation in the economy. These parties often support policies such as subsidies and higher taxes on the wealthy to redistribute wealth and address economic inequalities. In the context of India, most political parties can be considered economically left-wing as they favour subsidies and have the desire to raise taxes. It is worth noting that India had restrictions on foreign direct investment (FDI) until the 1990s, indicating a historically more closed economy.
- Socially left: Socially left political parties or administrations focus on advocating for revolutionary changes within the existing system, particularly regarding social issues. This includes positions on matters such as religion, abortion, same-sex marriage, and other social concerns. Socially left parties are often characterized by their secular stance. In India, political parties like the Indian National Congress (INC), Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), Janata Dal-United (JDU), All India Trinamool Congress (TMC), and Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) can be considered socially left due to their emphasis on secularism and progressive social policies.
It’s important to note that these classifications can vary and overlap, as left-wing ideologies encompass a broad spectrum of perspectives and priorities. Furthermore, the categorization of political parties may vary across different countries and contexts.
Role of Russian Revolution:
The Russian Revolution played a significant role in shaping the political landscape and inspiring anti-colonial movements, including in India. Here are some key points highlighting its impact:
- The overthrow of the Czarist regime: The Russian Revolution, led by the Bolshevik Party under Vladimir Lenin, resulted in the overthrow of the despotic Czarist regime on November 7, 1917. This event marked the establishment of the first socialist state.
- Inspiration for the colonial world: The Soviet regime’s decision to renounce imperialist rights in China and other parts of Asia had a profound impact on the colonial world. This action energized and motivated people in colonized nations, as they saw the possibility of uniting to challenge imperial powers.
- Revolutionary potential: The success of the Russian Revolution conveyed a powerful message to the Indian people who were fighting against British imperialism. It demonstrated that if the common people—workers, peasants, and intellectuals—could unite to overthrow a mighty empire and establish a society free from exploitation, the same could be achieved in India.
- Rise of socialist doctrines: The Russian Revolution and the guiding theory of the Bolshevik Party, Marxism, gained sudden popularity, particularly among Asians. Socialist ideologies began to resonate with those who sought social justice and an end to exploitation.
- Discontent with Gandhian and Swarajist approaches: The Russian Revolution had an impact on young individuals who actively participated in the Non-Cooperation Movement in India. Some were dissatisfied with the outcomes and the policies advocated by Mahatma Gandhi and the alternative Swarajist program. Socialist ideas quickly gained traction as an alternative to these approaches.
Overall, the Russian Revolution served as a catalyst for inspiring and spreading socialist ideals, energizing anti-colonial movements, and influencing the political thinking of individuals involved in the struggle for independence in India.
Several socialist and communist organizations sprang up across the country
During this period, various socialist and communist organizations emerged in different parts of India, and the participation of youth played a significant role in spreading socialist ideals. Here are some key points related to these developments:
- Socialist publications and founders: S.A. Dange published “Gandhi and Lenin” and established the first socialist weekly called The Socialist in Bombay. Muzaffar Ahmed published Navayug in Bengal and later collaborated with poet Nazrul Islam to create Langal. Ghulam Hussain and others published Inquilab in Punjab. M. Singaravelu founded the Labour-Kisan Gazette in Madras.
- Youth involvement: Starting from 1927, student and youth associations sprang up across the country. Numerous youth conferences were held in 1928 and 1929, where speakers advocated radical solutions to India’s political, economic, and social issues.
- Nehru and Bose’s campaigns: Prominent leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Bose actively campaigned across the country, denouncing imperialism, capitalism, and landlordism, while promoting socialist ideology.
- Socialist adoption by freedom fighters: Socialist ideas found resonance among revolutionary freedom fighters, including Chandrasekhar Azad and Bhagat Singh, who embraced socialism as part of their struggle against colonial rule.
- Growth of labour and peasant movements: Throughout the 1920s, labour and peasant movements experienced significant growth in India. The onset of the Great Depression in the 1930s further increased the popularity of socialist ideas. The high unemployment rates worldwide during the economic downturn highlighted the flaws of capitalism, drawing attention to Marxism and socialism.
These developments illustrate the rise of socialist and communist ideologies in India during this period, with youth playing an active role in spreading these ideas and various socialist publications contributing to the discourse. The challenging socio-economic conditions and the influence of global events like the Great Depression contributed to the growing popularity of socialist thought in India.
Contribution of Jawaharlal Nehru:
Jawaharlal Nehru, a prominent leader of the Indian national movement, made significant contributions to the socialist perspective within the Congress Party and the broader movement. Here are some key points highlighting Nehru’s role:
- Presidency and formation of the Congress Socialist Party: Nehru was elected as the president of the Indian National Congress in 1936 and 1937, reflecting the growing left-wing tendency within the party. He, along with Subhas Bose, who became the Congress president in 1938 and 1939, played a key role in the formation of the Congress Socialist Party.
- Socialism as a central component: Nehru advocated for a socialist perspective within the national movement. He emphasized that freedom should not be limited to political independence but should also encompass socio-economic emancipation. He popularized the idea that political freedom should be followed by the establishment of a socialist society.
- Influence and leadership: Nehru’s popularity and influence as a leader of the national movement were significant. He toured extensively, addressing millions of people and shaping the views of young nationalists. His books, articles, and speeches propagated socialist ideas, underscoring the importance of economic upliftment for the masses alongside political liberation.
- Exposure to socialist thought: Nehru’s interest in economic issues was sparked during his encounter with the peasant movement in eastern Uttar Pradesh in 1920-21. During his imprisonment in 1922-1923, he extensively studied the history of revolutions, including the Russian Revolution. He attended the International Congress against Colonial Oppression and Imperialism in Brussels in 1927, where he engaged with communists and anti-colonialists. These experiences led him to accept Marxism in its broader sense.
- Influence of the Soviet Union: Nehru visited the Soviet Union in 1927 and was deeply impressed by the socialist society he observed. Upon his return, he published a book about the Soviet Union, expressing his enthusiasm for the transformative changes taking place. Nehru’s exposure to the Soviet Union and socialist principles further solidified his commitment to revolutionary and radical ideologies.
- The Independence for India League: Nehru and Subhas Chandra Bose co-founded the Independence for India League in 1928, advocating for complete independence and a socialist revision of India’s economic structure.
- Commitment to socialism: Nehru’s commitment to socialism grew more pronounced during the years 1933-36. He emphasized the need for India to adopt a comprehensive socialist program to combat poverty and inequality. He criticized the existing imbalance between capital and labour, as well as between landlords and tenants, which favoured the capitalist and landlord classes.
Nehru’s influence and advocacy for socialist ideas played a significant role in shaping the perspectives of young nationalists and advancing the socialist discourse within the Indian national movement.
View of Gandhi:
During the period under discussion, Jawaharlal Nehru had a complex relationship with Mahatma Gandhi, particularly regarding their views on social and economic issues. Here are some key points highlighting Nehru’s perspective and his stance towards Gandhi:
- Emphasis on class analysis and class struggle: Nehru emphasized the importance of class analysis and class struggle during this time, which differed from Gandhi’s approach. He criticized Gandhi for not recognizing the class divide and advocating for harmony between exploiters and the exploited. Nehru also expressed disagreement with Gandhi’s theories of capitalist and landlord trusteeship and conversion.
- Defence of Gandhi’s revolutionary role: Despite his disagreements, Nehru defended Gandhi against left-wing critics. He acknowledged Gandhi’s revolutionary role, highlighting his ability to connect with the masses and utilize objective conditions effectively. Nehru recognized that Gandhi’s actions and teachings raised mass consciousness and made social issues significant in the national movement.
- The primacy of the anti-imperialist struggle: Nehru’s commitment to socialism was contextualized within the primacy of the political and anti-imperialist struggle as long as India remained under foreign rule. He aimed to reconcile his socialist commitments with the broader national movement without jeopardizing the anti-colonial objectives.
- Reconciling nationalism and socialism: Nehru expressed that his two fundamental motivations were nationalism and political freedom represented by the Congress, and social freedom represented by socialism. He believed in integrating these two outlooks into an organic whole. He opposed the idea of forming a separate organization or breaking with Gandhi and the right wing of the Congress, emphasizing the need to work within the Congress and engage its workers and peasants in the socialist cause.
- Transformation of the Congress: Nehru aimed to persuade and transform the entire Congress in a socialist direction. He believed that working under the Congress banner and involving workers and peasants within the organization would be the most effective way to achieve this goal. He cautioned against the left wing becoming a separate sect from the rest of the national movement, emphasizing the importance of maintaining unity.
Nehru’s views reflected a nuanced approach to reconciling his socialist ideals with the larger anti-colonial struggle led by Gandhi and Congress. He recognized Gandhi’s revolutionary impact while seeking to integrate socialist principles within the nationalist framework.
Involvement of Indian revolutionaries in Soviet Union Revolution
During this period, a significant number of Indian revolutionaries and exiles were attracted to the Soviet Union due to its revolutionary commitment. Here are some key points regarding their involvement:
- M.N. Roy and the formation of the Communist Party of India (CPI): M.N. Roy, a prominent Indian revolutionary, collaborated with Lenin to shape the Communist International’s policy towards colonies. In October 1920, Roy and six other Indians met in Tashkent and established the Communist Party of India (CPI).
- Left-wing presence within the Congress: The CPI encouraged its members to actively participate in the Indian National Congress and establish a strong left-wing presence in its various organs. They aimed to collaborate with other radical nationalists and work towards transforming the Congress into a more radical and mass-based organization.
- Formation of peasant and worker parties: The early Communists in India primarily focused on forming and working through peasant and worker parties. In November 1925, Muzaffar Ahmed, Qazi Nazrul Islam, Hemanta Kumar Sarkar, and others established the Labour-Swaraj Party of the Indian National Congress in Bengal, which was the first party of its kind. Similarly, a Congress Labour Party was formed in Bombay in late 1926, and a Kirti-Kisan Party was formed in Punjab.
These developments highlight the engagement of Indian revolutionaries and exiles with the Soviet Union and their efforts to establish communist and left-wing parties within the Indian National Congress. Their actions aimed to contribute to the radicalization of the Congress and foster a stronger leftist presence in the political landscape of India.
- Workers and peasant party:
- During this time, the Workers’ and Peasants’ Party (WPP) played a significant role in the Indian political landscape. Here are some key points regarding the WPP and its influence:
- Formation and composition: The Hindustani Labour Kisan Party had been in existence in Madras since 1923. By 1928, various provincial organizations merged to form the pan-India Workers’ and Peasants’ Party, consisting entirely of Communists.
- Goals and strategy: The WPP aimed to work within the Indian National Congress to give it a more radical orientation, transforming it into a “people’s party.” Simultaneously, the WPP sought to organize workers and peasants in independent class organizations, pursuing complete independence before moving towards socialism.
- Growth and influence: The WPP experienced rapid growth, particularly in Bombay, which led to an increase in communist influence within the Congress. Prominent Congress leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru and other radical Congressmen praised the efforts of the WPP in pushing for a more radical agenda within the party.
- Role in establishing a left-wing within the Congress: The WPP, along with Nehru, Subhas Bose, youth leagues, and other leftist forces, played a crucial role in establishing a strong left-wing presence within the Congress. They steered the Indian national movement towards a more left-leaning ideology and agenda.
- Trade union activities: The WPP made significant progress on the trade union front, playing a pivotal role in the resurgence of working-class struggles from 1927 to 1929. Their efforts allowed Communists to gain a strong foothold within the working-class movement.
- Setbacks in 1929 and beyond; Despite their progress, the rapid growth of communist and WPP influence within the national movement faced setbacks due to two developments in 1929 and subsequent years. The specifics of these developments are not mentioned in the provided information.
- The Workers’ and Peasants’ Party played a crucial role in promoting radical left-wing ideas within the Indian National Congress and contributing to the resurgence of working-class struggles. However, the exact nature of the setbacks faced by the WPP in 1929 and beyond would require further information to elaborate upon.
Q. What is the historical background of the left-wing movement in India?
Ans. The left-wing movement in India has roots dating back to the early 20th century and gained prominence during the Indian independence struggle when socialist ideas resonated with those seeking freedom from British colonial rule.
Q. Was the Indian National Congress associated with the left wing during the independence movement?
Ans. Yes, there were left-wing factions within the Indian National Congress that advocated for socialist and progressive policies. They worked alongside other Congress members to fight for independence.
Q. Who were some key left-wing leaders within the Indian National Congress?
Ans. Prominent left-wing leaders within the Congress included Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhas Chandra Bose, and Acharya Narendra Dev, who played crucial roles in shaping the party’s policies.
Q. What were the key contributions of the left wing within the Congress to the independence movement?
Ans. The left wing within the Congress emphasized economic and social justice, land reforms, and labor rights as integral components of the independence struggle.
Q. How did the left wing contribute to the Indian freedom struggle?
Ans. The left wing played a vital role in mobilizing the working class and peasants, advocating for their rights and fighting against colonial exploitation. They often led labor strikes and agitations.
Q. Were there any specific events or movements led by the left wing during the freedom struggle?
Yes, left-wing leaders played a prominent role in movements like the Quit India Movement and the Tebhaga Movement in Bengal, both of which aimed at achieving independence and social justice.
Q. What was the relationship between the left wing and other nationalist groups and leaders during the freedom struggle?
Ans. The left wing collaborated with other nationalist groups, including the Indian National Congress and the socialist factions of the All India Kisan Sabha, to achieve common goals of independence and socio-economic reforms.
In case you still have your doubts, contact us on 9811333901.
For UPSC Prelims Resources, Click here
For Daily Updates and Study Material:
Join our Telegram Channel – Edukemy for IAS
- 1. Learn through Videos – here
- 2. Be Exam Ready by Practicing Daily MCQs – here
- 3. Daily Newsletter – Get all your Current Affairs Covered – here
- 4. Mains Answer Writing Practice – here