Communism in Europe

Europe After 1945:

Communism Takes Hold in Eastern Europe

1. War of Words:
• In February 1946, Stalin delivered a pivotal speech asserting that "peaceful coexistence with the West is impossible until final victory over capitalism." This implied an inevitability of future conflicts between the USSR and capitalist Western nations.
• In response, Winston Churchill delivered his famous Iron Curtain speech in March 1946 during a U.S. visit, stating that "an Iron Curtain has descended over Europe." He called for a Western alliance to counter the communist threat.

What was the Iron Curtain?

• The term symbolized the lack of interaction between Eastern and Western Europe across various domains, including economic and trade ties, political relationships, and people-to-people contact. Churchill introduced this concept in his 1946 speech, responding to Stalin's earlier address. The Iron Curtain appeared to be a reality when Stalin prevented Eastern European nations, particularly Czechoslovakia, from accessing Marshal Aid (1947). The establishment of communism through an armed coup in Czechoslovakia reinforced the notion of an Iron Curtain.
• Events like the West Berlin Blockade (1948-49) and the construction of the Berlin Wall (1961-89) further affirmed the existence of an Iron Curtain in Europe.

1. Stalin's Consolidation of Communism:
• Following the Potsdam Conference and the use of nuclear weapons on Japan, Stalin exerted political influence in Eastern Europe. Pro-communist governments were installed in Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Albania, and Hungary. In some cases, opponents were imprisoned or even killed.
• By 1947, all states in Eastern Europe, except Czechoslovakia, had communist governments. Elections were manipulated, non-communist members of coalition governments were removed, and parties other than the communist party were dissolved. This all transpired under the watchful eyes of secret police and Russian troops. Stalin's actions angered the capitalist West, as he had violated the promise of "free elections" in Eastern Europe made during the Yalta conference. However, it's worth noting that in 1944, Churchill had consented to the idea of Eastern Europe falling under Russian influence.
2. Yugoslavia and Tito:
• In Yugoslavia, it was Josip Broz Tito who led the communists to victory against the Germans, not Soviet troops. Tito was a popular leader and was elected in 1945 through free and fair elections. The government formed under Tito was communist, but Tito resisted Soviet interference in Yugoslavia's internal affairs and foreign policy.

Truman Doctrine (March 1947):

The Truman Doctrine, announced in March 1947, marked a significant shift in U.S. foreign policy after World War II. It signified a departure from the policy of isolationism, which was followed after World War I. Instead, the Truman Doctrine embraced a policy of containment, where the U.S. committed to preventing the spread of communism not only in Europe but globally. Here are key aspects of the Truman Doctrine:

1. The objective of Containment:
• The primary goal of the Truman Doctrine was to contain the spread of communism, particularly in what the capitalist bloc referred to as the "Free World."
2. Origins in Greece:
• The Truman Doctrine found its roots in the events unfolding in Greece. After World War II, Britain, exhausted from the conflict, reinstated the monarchy in Greece. However, a civil war broke out, led by communists with support from communist governments in Albania, Bulgaria, and Yugoslavia. Unable to sustain the fight against Greek communists, Britain appealed to the U.S. for assistance. In response, President Truman articulated the Truman Doctrine, declaring that the U.S. would support free peoples against subjugation by armed minorities or external pressures. The U.S. subsequently assumed the responsibility and provided support to the Greek government in its battle against the communists. This intervention in Greece in 1947 marked the formal commencement of the Cold War.
3. Policy of Containment:
• The policy of containment took various forms in the years that followed:

a) Economic Measures: This included aid under the Marshall Plan (1947), aimed at bolstering the economies of Western European nations.

b) Military Bloc Building: The establishment of NATO (1949) served as a military alliance to counter the spread of communism.

c) Pursuit of Military Superiority: This involved striving for leadership in the arms race and the space race.

d) Political Interference and Election Rigging: The U.S. engaged in political interference, including rigging elections in third countries, to ensure the ascendancy of pro-capitalist governments. The objective was to safeguard U.S. economic and strategic interests.

• Examples of Political Interference:
• Italy (1948): The CIA openly admitted providing $1 million in aid to Christian and other anti-communist candidates favouring a capitalist multi-party democracy in the 1948 elections. Despite the Italian Communist Party's strong position, the Christian Democratic Party emerged victorious with substantial support due to CIA aid.
• Central America (1980s): In Nicaragua, the U.S., via the CIA, aided rebels in overthrowing a leftist government. In El Salvador, the U.S. supported an authoritarian regime under threat from leftist guerrillas.
• South America: U.S. support for brutal right-wing governments contributed to significant violence and political instability.
• Iran (1953): The U.S., concerned about Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh's alignment with the USSR, played a crucial role in orchestrating a coup against the democratically elected leader. This paved the way for Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi to establish his autocratic rule, closely aligned with the U.S. The Shah's eventual downfall in the 1979 Islamic Revolution stemmed from his clash with Shia clerics, who opposed his Western-style modernization initiatives for Iranian society.

Marshall Plan (June 1947):

Also known as the European Recovery Programme, the Marshall Plan was a significant initiative aimed at revitalizing Europe's economy after the devastation of World War II. While its official objective was to alleviate hunger, poverty, and chaos, it also had a concealed political agenda: containing the spread of communism. From 1947 to 1951, a staggering $130 billion (in today's terms) was allocated to Western Europe under the Marshall Plan. Here are some of its key impacts:

1. Swift Economic Recovery:
• The Marshall Plan played a pivotal role in the rapid recovery of Western Europe from the extensive damage inflicted by the war. It injected essential funds into the region, facilitating the reconstruction process.
2. Prosperity in Western Germany and Berlin:
• West Germany, along with West Berlin, experienced a surge in prosperity, creating a stark contrast with the economic conditions in East Germany, which was under Soviet control. The Soviet Union did not dedicate sufficient efforts toward the prosperity of its occupied zone in Germany, instead utilizing its resources to bolster the growth of the USSR. The long-term consequence of the Marshall Plan was the eventual fall of the Berlin Wall (1961-1989) and, ultimately, the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe.
3. Boost in U.S. Exports:
• The economic upswing, rising living standards, increased incomes, and overall development in Western Europe not only contributed to the region's recovery but also served as a burgeoning market for U.S. businesses. This resulted in a notable increase in U.S. exports.

The Marshall Plan is recognized as a pivotal element in the resurgence of Europe's economy and in consolidating the U.S. as a major global player during the post-war era.

Stalin’s Response to the Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan:

Stalin reacted strongly to the Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan, viewing them as a direct challenge to Soviet influence in Eastern Europe. He implemented several measures to counter these initiatives:

1. Molotov Plan (1947):
• The Molotov Plan was devised by Stalin as a response to the Marshall Plan. It provided economic assistance to the Soviet satellite states in Eastern Europe, thereby offering an alternative to the aid offered by the United States.
2. Cominform (Communist Information Bureau, 1947-1956):
• Cominform was established as a successor to the Comintern, which had operated from 1919 to 1943. Cominform included communist parties from various European nations and aimed to enhance Soviet control over its satellite states in Eastern Europe. It imposed strict guidelines on these parties, aligning their policies with those of the Soviet Union.
• Key Objectives of Cominform:
• Industrialization, collectivization, and centralization of Eastern Europe.
• Encouraging trade primarily among Cominform member nations, while discouraging contacts with non-communist countries.
• Yugoslavia was expelled from Cominform in 1948 due to its objections to some of the policies.
3. COMECON (Council for Mutual Economic Assistance, 1949-1991):
• COMECON was established to coordinate economic policies among the member nations of Cominform. It aimed to foster economic collaboration and integration among the communist states, thereby bolstering their collective strength.

These measures, taken together, represented Stalin's determined efforts to counteract the influence of the Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan in Eastern Europe and maintain Soviet dominance over the region.

Communist Takeover of Czechoslovakia (1948):

Czechoslovakia, in the aftermath of World War II, emerged as a multi-party democracy in Eastern Europe. The government was a coalition of communists and other left-wing parties, formed after the 1946 elections. Czechoslovakia sought to maintain a neutral position and act as a bridge between Western and Eastern Europe.

However, by 1948, tensions were rising. The impending elections presented a challenge for the communists, as public sentiment had turned against the government due to its rejection of Marshall Aid under Soviet pressure. Recognizing that they had little chance of winning the elections through legitimate means, the communists executed an armed coup.

Simultaneously, the USSR dispatched troops from its occupation zone in Austria to the Austrian-Czechoslovakian border, ensuring that the coup would proceed without interference. Although elections were held, only communist candidates were allowed to contest. The United Nations raised objections but was unable to take significant action as it couldn't conclusively prove direct Russian involvement. The Soviet Union argued that the coup was an internal matter, thus avoiding international intervention.

This event made it abundantly clear that the USSR was prepared to intervene forcefully if a satellite state showed inclinations towards adopting a pro-capitalist stance. The takeover of Czechoslovakia further solidified Soviet control over Eastern Europe and underscored the limitations of independence for the satellite states.

Division of Germany and West Berlin Blockade (1948-49):

Following the Yalta Conference in 1945, Germany and its capital, Berlin, were divided into four occupation zones, each controlled by Britain, France, the United States, and the Soviet Union.

In terms of economic policy, the Western powers—the US, Britain, and France—focused on the recovery and prosperity of their respective zones in Germany. In contrast, the USSR pursued policies that did not promote economic development.

This divergence in policy led to a stark contrast in the prosperity levels between the western zones and the Soviet-controlled zone in Germany. This disparity increased discontent among the population of the Soviet zone.

To further consolidate its control over East Berlin, the USSR took a drastic step by initiating the West Berlin Blockade in 1948. Here are the key details:

• What Was It? The West Berlin Blockade involved the complete closure of all transportation links (including rail, road, and canal) between West Berlin and West Germany.
• Intent? The primary objective of the blockade was to cut off supplies to West Berlin, effectively isolating it from the western zones, and thereby compelling the United States, Britain, and France to withdraw. The aim was for the USSR to gain full control over the entire city.
• Reasoning? The Soviet Union resorted to this action due to the growing challenges it faced in maintaining control over East Berlin. The stark contrast in economic prosperity between East and West Berlin, a consequence of the differing economic policies adopted by the Western powers and the USSR, played a significant role. Additionally, the introduction of a new currency by the Western powers made it untenable for the USSR to continue using two currencies in the same city.
• Airlift: In response to the blockade, the Western powers, especially the United States, launched a massive airlift operation to drop essential supplies into West Berlin. This operation lasted for a year and proved to be successful in nullifying the blockade.
• Brink of War: The situation became extremely tense, and the United States even stationed bomber planes in British airfields as a precautionary measure.

Ultimately, the West Berlin Blockade failed, and the USSR was compelled to lift the blockade. This event highlighted the determination of the Western powers to support West Berlin and demonstrated the resolve to resist Soviet efforts to gain complete control over the city. The Airlift, in particular, became a symbol of the resolve of the Western Allies during the early stages of the Cold War.

Impact of the West Berlin Blockade (1948-49):

1. Bittering of US-USSR Relations:

• The West Berlin Blockade intensified the already strained relationship between the United States and the Soviet Union. It became evident that Germany would remain divided for the foreseeable future, solidifying the division between East and West.

2. Formation of Separate German States:

• In response to the division, the United States, Britain, and France consolidated their zones in Germany, officially establishing the Federal Republic of Germany (commonly known as West Germany) in 1949. In parallel, the Soviet Union declared its zone as the German Democratic Republic (East Germany). This formalized the division of Germany into two distinct nations.

3. Creation of NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization):

• The West Berlin Blockade played a pivotal role in the formation of NATO in 1949. It was a mutual defence alliance established by Western powers, including Britain, France, the United States, Canada, Italy, Norway, Denmark, Portugal, Belgium, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Ireland. Members pledged to place their defence forces under a joint NATO command structure and adhere to the principle of collective security. The inclusion of Greece and Turkey followed in 1952, while West Germany joined in 1955.
• This marked a significant departure from the United States' previous policy of avoiding entangling alliances, as it now committed to military action in advance.

4. Economic Prosperity of West Germany:

• West Germany experienced remarkable economic growth and prosperity, primarily due to the policies and efforts of Western nations: a) Marshall Aid (1947): The introduction of Marshall Aid in 1947 provided substantial economic assistance, contributing to West Germany's recovery. b) Unification of Occupation Zones: In 1948, the United States, Britain, and France merged their occupation zones in Germany into a single economic entity, further bolstering recovery efforts. c) Formation of West Germany (1949): After the failed West Berlin Blockade, the three powers united their zones into the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949.
• In contrast, the economic policies of the Soviet Union in East Germany were focused on extracting resources for reparations and did not prioritize the region's economic recovery.

Ultimately, these events and policies contributed to the stark economic disparities between East and West Germany, laying the groundwork for the eventual reunification of Germany in December 1989, with communism coming to an end in East Germany.