The Safety Valve theory was formulated by radical figures in India, including Lala Lajpat Rai, Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, and various others.

Lala Lajpat Rai authored two books, namely 'Unhappy India' and 'Punjabi,' in which he elucidated and criticized British policies related to the formation of the Indian National Congress (INC). Rai asserted that the INC was established as a result of a conspiracy orchestrated by Lord Dufferin and A.O. Hume. This perspective, known as the safety-valve theory, gained prominence in Indian political discourse. The following article will delve into the Safety Valve Theory, offering insights beneficial for UPSC exam preparation.

Safety Valve Theory - Background

• Hume's involvement led to conspiracy theories on Congress's origins.
• W. C. Banerjee's claim of Hume acting for Lord Dufferin caused controversy.
• P. Dutt suggested Congress was formed under British oversight as a safety valve against discontent.
• This theory originated from William Wedderburn's 1913 biography of Hume.
• In 1878, Hume discovered seven volumes of reports on discontent and a plot to overthrow British rule.
• Hume and Lord Dufferin decided to establish an organization of educated Indians as a safety valve to prevent mass revolution.
• Imperialist historians dismissed Congress as a British creation, while Marxists used it for a conspiracy theory.
• P. Dutt argued Congress resulted from a British conspiracy, with bourgeois leaders complicit.
• Dufferin's private papers discredited the conspiracy theory, revealing no one took Hume's predictions seriously.
• No evidence of the secret report's existence was found in Indian or British archives.
• Dufferin criticized Congress for representing only a minority, refuting the safety valve theory.
• Historians labeled the seven-volume report as fiction.

Safety Valve Theory - Features

• According to the theory, Hume initiated the formation of the Congress with the expectation that it would act as a "safety valve" for the growing discontent among Indians. He successfully convinced Lord Dufferin not to hinder the establishment of the Congress.
• The primary aim was to create a platform for people to discuss their political concerns, positioning the INC as a buffer organization or a safety valve. This idea found support among extremist leaders like Lala Lajpat Rai, and even the Marxist historian's 'conspiracy theory' had its roots in the 'safety valve' concept.
• The notion of a "safety valve" is a subject of contention among modern Indian historians. According to their perspective, the Indian National Congress represented the aspirations of politically aware Indians to form a national body expressing their political and economic demands.
• With the surge of nationalism in the latter half of the nineteenth century, Indian opposition to British policies intensified. British strategists proposed a concept where a buffer organization, the Indian National Congress (INC), would stand between the British Government in India and the Indian public.
• As per the Safety Valve Theory, the British perceived the political situation in the country as potentially leading to a rebellion akin to the Mutiny of 1857. To avert such a scenario, they aimed to establish a forum for discussing political issues, with the INC being founded by a retired civil servant rather than by Indians.
• The INC's origin was attributed to Viceroy Lord Dufferin, assisted by a former Civil Services member, as a "Safety Valve" against popular discontent.

Safety Valve Theory - Arguments Put Forward

• A.O. Hume and fellow Britons held the belief that educated Indians could emerge as leaders, potentially leading a rebellion against the government. To preempt such a scenario, providing them a platform to express themselves was seen as a means to quell discontent.
• A.O. Hume, a retired British Civil Servant, held multiple meetings with Lord Dufferin, the Viceroy. Additionally, he engaged in lobbying efforts alongside figures like Sir James Caird, Lord Ripon, John Bright, and others.
• The support for A.O. Hume's endeavors extended to a significant number of British residents in India, including individuals like Sir William Wedderburn, George Yule, Charles Bradlaugh, and more. Their backing reflected a shared perspective on the potential efficacy of providing a platform for educated Indians to mitigate potential unrest.

About Lala Lajpat Rai

• Lala Lajpat Rai, born on 28th January 1865 and passing away on 17th November 1928, was a significant figure in India's struggle for independence, contributing as a freedom fighter, author, and politician. Recognized as Punjab Kesari, he formed one-third of the Lal Bal Pal triumvirate.
• His demise occurred shortly after sustaining severe injuries during a police baton charge while leading a peaceful protest march against the all-British Simon Commission. This commission, initiated by the United Kingdom to reform Indian constitutional law, became a focal point of resistance.
• Lala Lajpat Rai faced deportation to Mandalay after aligning with the Indian National Congress and participating in political activities in Punjab. However, insufficient evidence prevented his subversion charges. In December 1907, his supporters made an unsuccessful attempt to elect him as the president of the party during the Surat session.
• During the Calcutta Special Session of 1920, Lajpat Rai was elected as the President of the Indian National Congress. In 1921, he founded the Servants of the People Society, a non-profit organization dedicated to welfare initiatives.
• Among his literary contributions, Lala Lajpat Rai authored two significant books, namely 'Unhappy India' and 'Punjabi.' In these works, he meticulously elucidated and critiqued British policies concerning the formation of the Indian National Congress.

Conclusion

The Safety Valve Theory posited that the British, concerned about the potential for political unrest akin to the 1857 Mutiny, sought to prevent such a scenario. To avert rebellion, they aimed to create a platform for open discussions on political matters. Although this theory is no longer widely accepted, it is essential to acknowledge the British role in establishing the inaugural all-India political front, predominantly comprising Hindus. While the Muslim response to the Congress was initially unfavorable, notable leaders like Badruddin Taybji played an active role in shaping the narrative.